Disconnect the woofer


If I was to unhook the wires to the woofer of my (non-biwireable) 3 way speakers, would the crossover parts that make up the low pass to the woofer still be using up energy from my amp, or is there no energy loss since the circuit is not completed?

I am thinknig of active bi-amping the woofers with another amp and letting the mid/tweeter run off my orignial amp.
koestner

Showing 3 responses by almarg

I agree with Rodman. It depends on the crossover configuration. If it is more than a first order crossover (i.e., an inductor in series with the woofer), you would want to open the INPUT to the low frequency part of the crossover network, not its output which is connected to the woofer.

Regards,
-- Al
Contrary to audiophile wisdom, crossover networks "soak up" almost no power, even when all the drivers are connected. If they did they would get hot, and if mounted in a sealed enclosure stuffed with fiberglass or wool, very hot.

Yes, inductors and capacitors do not dissipate significant power. However I would think that there would be some sonic benefit with many amplifiers to disconnecting the woofer's crossover elements, because the reactive (inductive and capacitive) load seen by the amplifier would be minimized.

Disconnecting the load on the low pass leg may affect characteristics of the high pass leg.

I believe that is only true for the relatively small number of speakers which are designed with the crossover legs in series. In those cases, a low pass filter is connected across the high frequency driver, a high pass filter is connected across the low frequency driver, and the two filters (and consequently the two drivers) are connected in series. The unwanted frequencies for each driver are shunted (bypassed) around the driver. But that kind of design is uncommon, I believe. More typically, the multiple crossover legs are in parallel and do not interact.

Koestner -- If you were thinking of leaving the low pass crossover elements unused, I'm not sure how you are planning to make the rolloff of the signal applied to the woofer complementary to the rolloff of the high pass part of the crossover. I think you would have to use an electronic crossover ahead of the low frequency amplifier, set to provide a low pass function for the woofer with rolloff carefully matched to what those crossover elements originally provided.

Regards,
-- Al
Koestner -- Since the Maggies are designed for both bi-wiring and bi-amping, and you are using their passive crossover to feed the mid/high frequency section, why didn't you just disconnect the low frequency section by removing the jumper from the low frequency crossover input?

Rodman99999: The 20.1 crossover is jumpered, and as long as you are removing the LF signal from the input, via an active x-over(with jumpers removed); you shouldn't have any issues.

It sounds like he is not doing that. He is supplying a full-range signal to the Maggies, which goes through the speaker's passive crossover to the high frequency panels. And he's using an electronic (active) equalizer to provide a low-pass function for the signal which is applied to the separate open baffle subs. I suppose that's within reason, if not ideal.

Regards,
-- Al