Can you help pinpoint why I am now satisfied with my digital setup?


Why ask why?  Bud dry. Right?  Why ask if you are satisfied? Just be. Here goes....

I put out a thread recently how I couldn't get my digital to sound good enough to listen for hours on end.  It sounded great, but nowhere close to my analog front end. Many users recommended I might try an R2R DAC.  While researching those and other solutions, I did the following: 

Instead of feeding my Primaluna integrated with the NAD M51 DAC, I ran the NAD M51 analog out in XLR/balanced to a Schitt Freya, then I ran single ended RCA out from the Schitt to the Primaluna.  I turned the Schitt preamp volume attenuator to its maximum.  Voila!  Well, maybe not equal to my vinyl front end, but I can now listen for way longer periods. 

The NAD M51 is not what you'd call an overbearing DAC sound.  I'd say it's neutral to the warm side of neutral.  

I thought the short answer was the improvement is because I'm adding a tube buffer, vis-à-vis the Schitt Freya, to the DAC output signal.  But, wasn't I buffering the signal before when I fed the NAD DAC to the Primaluna?  Is the improvement due to tubes on tubes (Freya on Primaluna)?  

I also note that in the summer when I ran the NAD M51 into the Freya driving an NAD M22 amp I felt nearly the same as I did running the NAD into the Primaluna.  Is this just tubes on tubes?  I see no other explanation.  

I'm a bit fussy so I've been hesitant to say this solved the problem without extensive listening.  But now that I'm a week in to this setup, I find it works and think that will remain my long term view.  



128x128jbhiller

Showing 3 responses by jbhiller

Steve N. Thank you!!!!  That makes sense.  I really appreciate the technical explanation.
@mahler123, Yes, my objective was to push my digital front end up a bit (better it so I could listen longer).  The reason I want to do that is I really like exploring the catalog on Tidal before I buy vinyl, which I'm not yet familiar.  Some have said I should just stick with vinyl but that misses the objective--I cannot just buy records to no end.  I have to lay out the cash and just as important I have to store them.  I don't want a 10,000 album collection.  I like to listen to each album in my collection. 

So I think the situation is much much better with the Freya feeding the Primaluna with my DAC feed than the DAC direct to the Primaluna.  But, and it's a big BUT, this sounds better, not ideal.  I can live with it.  

I spent hours last night comparing the best recordings I could find digitally that are also in my vinyl collection, with the criteria that they had to be favorites or recordings I really like and knew very well.  Vinyl won out. 

Tonight I'm listening to digital because I'm exhausted and don't have much time.  I had my kid all day and the wife is doing bed time, so I wanted to keep it simple and just listen and not have to get up much to deal with records.  Well, digital is fine, just not as engaging. 

The holographic picture I get with vinyl and my cart/preamp is just intoxicating when things are right.