Archiving CDs to HD...suggestions?


i'm thinking of moving and wondering the best way to consolidate my 3k CD collection to a hard drive, which would be much easier to move.

clearly i'd go into PC/Mac-based audio in my new abode.

but a few questions first:
1) does the cd drive matter to the rip? or do i just need to use a good software like EAC or the like to ensure an accurate rip?

2) if i rip on a PC, do i have to use a PC in the future, or can i use a Mac against my external music store if it was created under a PC?

3) what sort of redundancy is in order? RAID 1? RAID 5? or just another HD the same as the one i plan on playing from, and simply use it as a backup?

4) which uncompressed file format should i use? AAC or something else?

5) any estimate of how much storage would be required for 3k CDs? or would it be feasible to split my music collection across 2 primary HDs...like A-L, M-Z...which is really asking if playback software can read across multiple drives in one virtual "library"

6) are rips sensitive to vibrations, power conditioning, etc?

thanks for any suggestions
RC
128x128rhyno

Showing 1 response by jax2

A few important notes on format:

I'd strongly discourage you from using WAV files for lack of metadata support which will make your life living hell if you ever have to move files around, share files, or restore from a backup. Just don't do it.

If you are using iTunes to manage your library it will NOT support FLAC in its native form. You would have to use some add-on software like Amarra or Pure Music in order to use FLAC files. Otherwise FLAC is an excellent choice as it does work with a whole lot of options in software and is cross-platform.

As has been noted already, the software that you use to rip the files initially will make a significant difference. The drive will not. Good recommendations already for EAC (PC only) or XLD. I'd add Max to the list for Mac, and I would avoid ripping in iTunes because the error correction is not great. Make sure to have the error-correction set in whatever software you choose to the most vigorous setting (in Max that would be "Full Paranoia" using CD Paranoia as error correction).

Mirrored RAID is what you want. I believe that is RAID 1. Good advice already about the drive size (2-3tb with room for expansion). I would further advise you get good raw HD units for the RAID device such as WD Black Caviar or Hitachi Ultrastar Enterprise. The components used to build those drives are superior to the cheaper drives (some from the same manufacturers) and they have a higher MTBF rating, FWIW. Any drive can fail though, so backup is absolutely a must and RAID is a great way to do it.

You might also look to ComputerAudiophile.com for further info and opinions.

Good luck