Stylus For Gauge - Do I really need one?

The gauge recognizes only stylus force; it cannot distinguish cartrige compliance.

It is not the effect of compiance on the guage, it is the guages usefullness in getting the VTF as close as possible to the manufacturing specs that matters. Higher end cartridges are more responsive to getting the VTF right and they tend to be of medium to low compliance. The Shure guage is just not that good.

>>Higher end cartridges are more responsive to getting the VTF right and they tend to be of medium to low compliance.<<

No. That is not correct. There are many "higher end" cartridges of medium to high compliance i.e. 15+ that require precise VTF adjustments. The list, although not comprehensive, includes Zyx, Clearaudio, Benz Micro, van den Hul, Grado, etc.

Actually most any cartridge requires precise VTF adjustment for optimum performance be it high or low compliance. The gauge, as you point out, serves as a starting point; final settings must be based on the user's ears. If you accept this premise than your argument is flawed.

>

All the more reason to use a better guage. It is the starting point I'm considering here and yes the final determination is done by ear. This has been beat to death elsewhere so in short, you use whatever you want. I consider compliances around 10 to 15 to be medium which is where most of the carts in your list are. Now take a Shure up in the 20-25 range, that's high compliance to me. But again, you use whatever you think works for you.