Reviewers: Let's End the AI-Generated Content


I recently came across the review of a tube amp that I was excited to learn more about, a review on a well-known site by someone whose reviews I've enjoyed in the past. But as I began reading, something was not quite right. Phrases like "the dulcet tones of the amplifying device revolved around the listening environment" and "the KT170 amplifier tubes were more than worthy in generating timbres of truest fidelity" were peppered from beginning to end. WHAT? I am seeing these AI-generated sentences more and more in reviews, and my message to these reviewers is threefold: 1] You only make yourself look bad when you choose to incorporate AI into your writing 2] Your readers are not stupid 3] Your readers deserve better. And to the editors who have a responsibility as content gatekeepers, step up and hold reviewers accountable for original content...your readers will thank you.

bojack

I agree 100%. Actually I'm not in favor of that AI at all..n. I've watched too many old sci-fi movies but the white thing seems sinister to me

2  typos  but not allowing me to erase which they have no right to do. I don't like that at ALL 

I like my ai robot it does my dishes and hums.my next model up will have a streamer dac amp speaker combo.enjoy the music and reviews.

@jijoh123 "Stupid is.... as stupid does."

You go Forest!yes

@erik_squires "Recently an article was quoted on A'gon which claimed to prove the audibility of subwoofer placement.  The article appeared to be 100% ripped from a single, recent scientific paper.  The author gave no credit to the original author and did not mention his "facts" as not being peer reviewed, or confirmed in any other publication. 

The use of AI in this industry is out of control, and sometimes appears to be unethical."

So, @erik_squires Where are your citations? You could have included a link to the post you're talking about to clarify your assertion.

 

 

@ghdprentice since you mentioned bamboo slide rules I asked Gemini a question regarding metal vs bamboo. The question was “Does ambient temperature affect metal slide rule accuracy? Are bamboo slide rules better in this case”?

FWIW, I was a Post bamboo guy. Never liked the K&E metal rules.

Gemini:
Yes, ambient temperature can affect the accuracy of metal slide rules, and bamboo slide rules are generally considered better in terms of dimensional stability against temperature and humidity changes.
🌡️ Effect of Temperature on Metal Slide Rules
The primary way ambient temperature affects metal slide rules is through thermal expansion.
 * Thermal Expansion: Like all materials, the metal components (typically aluminum or magnesium alloy) of a slide rule will expand when the temperature rises and contract when the temperature drops.
 * Accuracy Impact: This change in length, though small, can introduce error into the calculations because the engraved or printed scales on the rule are dimensionally altered. While slide rules are inherently imprecise compared to modern calculators (offering about three significant figures of accuracy), thermal expansion can push the scale markings slightly out of their correct mathematical positions, further reducing the achievable accuracy.
 * Differential Expansion: If a metal rule is made of different materials, or if the main body and the sliding part (the slide) are subjected to different temperatures or have different coefficients of thermal expansion, the scales may not maintain their intended alignment, which can bind the slide or introduce reading errors due to misalignment.
🎍 Bamboo Slide Rules: A Better Option
Bamboo slide rules, particularly the famous Japanese "Hemmi" rules, are generally favored for their superior stability in fluctuating environments.
 * Dimensional Stability: Well-seasoned, quality bamboo is known to resist warping, shrinking, or lengthening significantly better than other materials (like typical hardwoods) when exposed to changes in temperature and humidity.
 * Self-Lubricating: Bamboo is also naturally somewhat self-lubricating, which helps the slide move smoothly and consistently, a performance feature that can indirectly affect the ease and therefore the practical accuracy of setting a reading.
 * Mitigation of Error: While not perfectly immune, the superior dimensional stability of bamboo means the scales are less likely to shift their relative positions due to environmental changes, making them a more reliable choice in conditions where temperature and humidity are not strictly controlled.
In summary, for situations where ambient temperature and humidity are variable, a bamboo slide rule offers a significant advantage over a metal or common wooden one in maintaining its dimensional stability and, consequently, its inherent accuracy.