In the past I would have dogmatically agreed that platter mass was a key point for good analog playback. I still think its a key contributor.
However the Well Tempered Reference has shown me that is not a bit t Truth. I bet its platter does not weigh over 5 pounds, yet it has excellent sound quality, has solid speed stability, excellent bass response, and portrays space in a very believable manner. Is it the best table? No. But for its price point it was a very good table, and viable even in todays marketplace. It may not have a lot of techno wiz bang options, but it still gets to the heart of the music. Mass alone does not define SQ.