Speaker Purchase


When I was in college, a neighbor who'd done well on Wall Street gave me a pair of Bose 901's when he upgraded to something else. Around that time, I purchased an Adcom GFA 545II (100 WPC into 8 ohms), and an Adcom Preamp. I also have a (now performing erratically) Carver CD Player. These components were acquired around 20 years ago and I'm now feeling they, well, are harsh sounding. In part, I've come to my own conclusion about this, but the feeling has been reinforced by hearing some friends' systems (Classe, McIntosh), and hearing the profound difference. I'm obviously not an Audiophile (though I love nice gadgets), and I admit to being fairly lost when reading reviews. I totally get the 'soundstage' concept, and I get the 'fatiguing' concept (because that's what my system does to me after a short while).

So, I've decided to upgrade, and I'm humbly asking for some advice. I've decided to spend under $10K, over a couple of years, and to start with new speakers. I would like to keep the cost of speakers under $5K (including reasonably decent cables and tax). The other $5K has to get me an integrated amp, CD player and turntable. I've so far noticed and think I would like to audition the following speakers: (1) PSB Synchrony One; (2) Vienna Acoustics Beethoven Baby Grand or (3) Concert Grand; (4) Sonus Faber Grand Piano Domus, and (5) B+W 804S.

The room these will go in is quite large and irregular. The room itself is 22'X25' with 20' ceilings. Ceiling and floors are concrete. One (left) wall has four 14' windows, one (ahead) wall is sheetrock, the wall against which the system will be placed is brick, and the right side opens to more space. The floor has a 12'X15' sheepskin, and the wall of windows has floor to ceiling drapes. But, my point is, the space is large, open and reflective.

I tend to listen to lots of music types: opera/classical, classic rock, alternative. The system is not intended for home theater (I have another room for that). I won't have a specific 'listening chair', so the quality of the sound can't be heavily dependent on my specific location vis-a-vis the speakers.

I'd greatly appreciate any advice--keeping it real--about what to listen for, what to avoid. I'm in NYC, BTW, so I have retail options. Thanks very much.
anker
You absolutely need to take your own music. You should select a few cd's (and some vinyl if you have it) that you know well, and that fits the overall genre of what you like to listen to. This will help you establish a baseline across multiple listening sessions. It also sends the message that you are serious about buying to the folks you are buying from.

This second thing is a lot harder though. Realize that you can do much better buying used. but it's pretty unethical to demo equipment at a brick and mortar store knowing you intend to buy elsewhere used.

That leaves you in a quandry. Most times you can re-sell your used purchases at a price very close to what you paid for them. That makes buying used a relatively low financial risk. But since you have not spent much time listening to what's available, you probably need the help of local stores to see what you like.

In my opinion, you'll need to suck it up and pay the brick and mortar premium. You can certainly look for used in those stores which will save you the new premium.

You can also build the system up slowly...with the main purchase being the speakers at the store. Then you can cycle through the up stream components in the used market until you are compfortable with your overall sound.

Good luck...this is a fun journey you are embarking on.
Thanks all. In particular, thanks Musicnoise for some obviously useful advice. I will make it a point to listen for both subtlety and intensity, and to listen for longer periods. I'll bring some of my own music, and try to test the speakers using amplification that's in the range of what I later intend on acquiring (no sense in testing it on equipment I'll never replicate). Again, I really appreciate the insights. Ultimately, I'll post where I wound up with all this, and my impressions (FWIW).
I had the same ethical quandry about spending two hours listening to equipment retail, with no intention of buying retail, which was feeding into my hesitancy about the used market. Thanks for echoing that.