What's up with that?

Swampwalker is correct about the reason, of course, but I don't understand those talking about “membership fees.” Then what, would only “members” be able to see each other's e-mail addresses? Why make things more complicated than they already are? Simply charge whatever fee is needed up front when the ad is placed, and then who gives a crap if we e-mail each other. I personally don't care what they charge, but charge it up front. Flat fee, fee based on selling price, reduced fee for relisting the same ad, I don't care. There is no venue with a better readership for web based sales of audio equipment and the stuff we are selling costs thousands of dollars. Just charge a reasonable fee up front, keep it simple and lose the restrictions.

Mitch2, this isn't just about contacting people about ads......90% of my contacting members was for discussion threads, not sales ads.....That's the part I miss, when reading the forums I used to be able to just click on a members name and send them an note offline.

Jmcgrogan2, I agree with you. The best discussions were simply sharing ideas and experiences and had nothing to do with buying and selling. The only reason I can think of for them not to share the e-mail addresses is that they believe folks might try and trade outside the system to bypass the percentage fee. By charging their fee up-front they would remove that threat. Can anyone else think of another reason A'gon doesn't want us communicating off-line?

Audiogon, if you are listening, thank you for letting this thread go on, and please feel welcome to jump in and help us understand your thoughts on this topic.