Record Cleaner Side Effects?


My vinyl collection is expanding and I am feed up with borrowing a friend's top of the line VPI ( before he can part with this holy grail of cleaning machines for the weekend I gotta kiss his _$$ , do a ceremonial bow down combined with backwards walking from the moment I leave his front door untill I can reach my car meanwhile he and his girlfriend smile at my display of graciousness. All this is happening fast enought so that the neihbors don't see the embarrassing display). Not really, but sometimes it feels like that when borrowing something expensive from someone else. Now to the point: Recently I came across an old issue of The Absolute Sound magazine and read an article in which the author was stating that record cleaning machines and their chemicals do more HARM than GOOD. The author did not state reasons/proof to validate his claim and instead he refered back to an earlier issue that covered his argument (and I don't happen to own this issue). I've always believed that record cleaning machines provide the best method for removing contaminants...we are after all taking the grime off the grooves aren't we? Any vinyl addicts here aware of reasons not to clean records using this method? Anybody hear about issues with the solvents more than the machine (new vs. old formulas, certain brands, chemical residues left behind on groves)? I am no expert on this subject and would like to get more input from someone more knowledgeable on this subject. I just know there are several vinyl gurus reading this that can shed some light. Also any recommendations on sub $500 machines (low end VPI, mid-upper end Nitty Gritty)? All info highly appreciated.
one_audiophile

Showing 1 response by lugnut

Hi,

IMNSHO, record cleaning is a no-brainer. I've been collecting vinyl for over 35 years and see/hear no evidence that record cleaning machines damage the software. On the contrary, failure to do so will embed debris into the vinyl permanently. Remember, the solvents used in commercial and home brew cleaners contact the recording for a very short duration and by design are compatible with vinyl, leaving no residue. Following machine cleaning place the disks in polyethylene sleeves and use a carbon fiber brush before and after each play. Clean your stylus often with a brush and periodically with a commercial cleaner. Replace your cartridge before the stylus is worn to a point of damaging the vinyl.

I recommend a vacuum record cleaning machine although it matters little if the cleaning is done automatically or not. So, your choice of machine should be determined by your budget, the volume of work to be done and the level of labor you are willing to invest with each disk. The basic Nitty Gritty and Disk Doctor machines are likely 99% as effective as the most expensive machines. DIY plans are available online. If you are handy and buy the vacuum source at a yard sale you can build a great cleaner for less than $20.

Using a commercial vinyl lubricant (Gruv Glide) or a vinyl preservative (Last) is a personal decision that, IMO, will not damage the recording and will most likely add to its life expectancy.

Develop a routine of proper handling and storage of your music and your great grand children will be enjoying your library long after your passing.

Others may take issue with my suggestion for polyethylene sleeves saying that rice paper is preferred. I'm the only person I know that has done a burn test on every available sleeve that I could find. Even the outlets that advertize rice sleeves are actually supplying polyethylene. Sleeves available for as little as 7 cents each (Sleeve City) are chemically identical to VPI sleeves at nearly 50 cents each. Rice paper sleeves were manufactured long ago and, to the best of my knowledge, are no longer available. They can be identified by folded and glued edges and crack with age.

These are just the opinions of an old fart that still enjoys my oldest recordings as much as the newest. Still, they are worth exactly what you paid for them.

Enjoy,
Patrick