Ouch Dbphd, double negative in your sentence, that was painful to read!
Isn't the case not really using HDMI vs analog, but using the Oppo's DAC converter vs the Onkyo or PS3?
i.e. using Analog outputs sounds better with the Oppo because the Oppo SE's higher quality DAC's are being utilized, while if HDMI was used for audio, the lower quality DAC in the Onkyo would be used.
Isn't the case not really using HDMI vs analog, but using the Oppo's DAC converter vs the Onkyo or PS3?
i.e. using Analog outputs sounds better with the Oppo because the Oppo SE's higher quality DAC's are being utilized, while if HDMI was used for audio, the lower quality DAC in the Onkyo would be used.