Haven't heard the CD5x but I own the Naim CD5 and the CDX2 and the Linn unidisk SC. I have also done a good bit of experimenting with hard disk servers connected to DACs (mine is the musical fidelity trivista). There are a few things which experimenting with multiple combinations of the above have become clear to me. I always preferred the way the music sounded coming from a Naim CD player over a Linn. The CD5 was even preferred over my Unidisk SC so when I upgraded source I chose the CDX2 rather than a "better" unidisk like the 2.1. The convenience of the hard disk server cannot be beat however if your system has pretty decent components/cables etc. you will most likely readily discern how superior the music sounds coming from an excellent CD player (I still don't understand exactly why this is but I have proven it to myself over and over). I have experimented with everything from the recorded bit rate (wav, lossless, whatever uncompressed form you like), to different sound cards, to external dacs, to most recently using the wireless apple airtunes optical -> DAC. The CDX2 always smokes it. But it is getting much better the more I experiment with it. Remeber, these issues are all relative, I don't mean to imply that any of the combinations or pieces of equipment sounded BAD they all sound quite good (except maybe a basic sound card directly into line level preamp) and it is just a matter of degree of refinement. Good Luck.
Looking at source enhancement for my new Sophia 2s
Took delivery of my new Sophia 2's on Monday and they sound great out of the box. Probably 95% broken in by now.
I'm driving them with a McIntosh MA2275 integrated tube amp which I deliberately chose a few months ago with the Sophia in mind, and the results are very satisfying. I listen to a broad range of music - today I played a lot of Johnny Cash's later stuff (the 4 cd set of the "American" series which by the way is just brilliant), some Van the Man, Morrisey, Aretha Franklin, Aimee Mann, Stan Getz... I listen to jazz and classical 10% of the time (but nothing too 'complex').
My current source is the McIntosh MS300 hard drive system, which is essentially a fancy Escient. It sounds excellent and is on a par with my other source which is a Rotel 1060 DVD Audio player (not a bad system as I couldn't tell the difference between this and a Naim CD5x when I demo'd it for a few days with my B&W 804s last year, although could have been the speakers/Rotel 5 channel amp which didn't let the Naim reach potential).
However I'm wondering now that I have these superior speakers and Amp, would I notice if I upgraded to an external DAC so I could feed the hard disk system into it. The other option is a Linn Unidisk SC, which has a digital input which I could feed the hard disk drive into (so I could keep the convenience of the hard disk with the DAC of the Linn and also use it as a source for DVD and maybe CD directly on it if it sounded good. I've heard that the Linn SC sounds pretty good and bests the Naim CD5x. I have yet to demo it however.
I'm of the view that the hard drive is the way forward for digital music, so maybe a good DAC would be the best long term solution.
I don't know too much about them, so I would appreciate any suggestions on a DAC or any other solution such as any other disc players with good internal DAC and digital input.
Are external DACs worth it or is it marginal? (I'm not a raving audiophile but I'd rather get a good one than an 'OK' one that didn't give me much of a noticeable upgrade). If anyone has experience of what they can do for a setup such as mine, then assuming a good DAC gave you a satisfaction level of 100, where do you think I am today with my current setup (i.e is it 97, 87 or 77?).
Cheers
I'm driving them with a McIntosh MA2275 integrated tube amp which I deliberately chose a few months ago with the Sophia in mind, and the results are very satisfying. I listen to a broad range of music - today I played a lot of Johnny Cash's later stuff (the 4 cd set of the "American" series which by the way is just brilliant), some Van the Man, Morrisey, Aretha Franklin, Aimee Mann, Stan Getz... I listen to jazz and classical 10% of the time (but nothing too 'complex').
My current source is the McIntosh MS300 hard drive system, which is essentially a fancy Escient. It sounds excellent and is on a par with my other source which is a Rotel 1060 DVD Audio player (not a bad system as I couldn't tell the difference between this and a Naim CD5x when I demo'd it for a few days with my B&W 804s last year, although could have been the speakers/Rotel 5 channel amp which didn't let the Naim reach potential).
However I'm wondering now that I have these superior speakers and Amp, would I notice if I upgraded to an external DAC so I could feed the hard disk system into it. The other option is a Linn Unidisk SC, which has a digital input which I could feed the hard disk drive into (so I could keep the convenience of the hard disk with the DAC of the Linn and also use it as a source for DVD and maybe CD directly on it if it sounded good. I've heard that the Linn SC sounds pretty good and bests the Naim CD5x. I have yet to demo it however.
I'm of the view that the hard drive is the way forward for digital music, so maybe a good DAC would be the best long term solution.
I don't know too much about them, so I would appreciate any suggestions on a DAC or any other solution such as any other disc players with good internal DAC and digital input.
Are external DACs worth it or is it marginal? (I'm not a raving audiophile but I'd rather get a good one than an 'OK' one that didn't give me much of a noticeable upgrade). If anyone has experience of what they can do for a setup such as mine, then assuming a good DAC gave you a satisfaction level of 100, where do you think I am today with my current setup (i.e is it 97, 87 or 77?).
Cheers