How come Horn + woofer designs are not more popular?


A couple guys on my audio discord really love the JBL synthesis 4367 and feel that all traditional 3 way tower speakers suck because they have poor bass response and are generally shy sounding. What I wonder is how come the majority of speaker makes do floor standers that are 3 way as oppose to the Horn +woofer design of JBL?

Is there any downsides to the horn + woofer design? Can a horn convey microdetail as well as a Be tweeter like say from magic A or S line? They claim 3 way floor standers are just trendy. But is there anything more to it then that?
smodtactical

Showing 1 response by ottuso

Speaking purely subjectively, for me speaker brands highlighted different things.  As a musician, I prefer to evaluate audio with music that doesn't rely on amplification for its realization, hence acoustic instruments.  Since I was a young teen, I've loved the way piano sounds on JBLs (I've had a Steinway grand almost since then).  I was blown away when I heard Wagner on a pair of Bozak Concert Grands.  Strings always had an unmatched warmth for me on KLH.

I've owned and loved JBLs since a teenager (over 50 years ago!), acquiring a bass reflex system with D130s alone at first, adding "potato masher" horns around 1970.  I still have them, and recently hooked in a pair of O75s.  In the early 1990s, I lucked upon a Paragon and vintage McIntosh MC240 & MC275 amps.  At first, I thought the sound impressive, but a bit harsh with weak bass.  The harshness increased as one moved closer to the horns, of course.  Subsequently, I learned that the previous owner listened at less than a moderate level (he had a cheap L Pad attached to it for convenient volume adjustment!)  I added a graphic equalizer and used it for years until I noticed that the (stiff?) 150C woofers had blossomed.  I took the equalizer offline and added a pair of JBL 2405s in parallel with the O75s.

My friends, mostly professional musicians, never failed to be impressed.  However, for me, there was yet a ways to go.  Five years ago I installed a McIntosh MEN220, "Room Perfect" component—bi-amped with an MC2105 for the low end and the MC275 for the horns and tweeters.  After running the room correction algorithm, I found that a great majority of what I had perceived as shortcomings were essentially gone.  There's nothing like live music, but this system continues to give me a thrill.