FP screen , +$$$ = better pic - fact or fiction?


About to venture into my first front projection system. Most likely will be Sony VPL-VW60 (1080P). Will use approx. 100" fixed mount screen - in a basement room where controlling light is not an issue. Will use for movies and sporting events. Viewing distance is 14-18'.

Is there really a significant picture quality difference when going from paint-on screen, to $1,000. screen to $3,000.+ screen? With the cost of the Sony unit, WAF budget dictates a sub-$1,200 screen. Will that be a mistake? Open to suggestions/recommendations ...
northwoods_maine

Showing 1 response by kartracer

Just a note when balancing projector vs. screen budget. Projector technology/quality improvement is still on a moderately steep climb while prices are dropping. I'm thinking screen technology is fairly mature (but I'm no expert here.) What I did a year ago was buy the best screen I could afford (a DaLite acoustically transparent tab-tensioned hi-contrast gray motor controlled, 110".) I bought a Panasonic 720p projector (even though 1080p was out, why pay for bleeding edge?) which was several hundred dollars less than the screen.

The philosophy here is, I should never have to upgrade the screen (cuz it would be a b!tch to sell/ship here or on Videogon!) but will most likely upgrade the projector down the road. I did pick this screen material based on the current projector and the only thing I would do differently is go with a white/higher gain screen. My room can be made totally dark, but even with the default light output, most scenes are on the dark side.

With all that said, I am quite pleased with the end result. Picture quality is very good with OTA HD broadcasts, as well as DirecTV HD, and Santa brought a Toshiba HD-A3 HD DVD player, but it's too early to tell how great it is. It does upscale standard DVDs to better PQ as the AVS forums attest.

This replaced a Sony 65" RPTV 16x9 HD which was a big acoustic mass (mess) between my main speakers. The projector hanging from the ceiling and the screen that rolls up into the ceiling take no floor space. The only downside is the setup (2-channel and home theatre combined in the same space) limits my placement of the main speakers. Overall it works well.

Mike