Distortions that the human ear likes. Are there any ?


This is based on a post from another thread, where someone speaking to a studio mastering engineer, repeated a quote by this engineer, stating " most audiophiles like certain distortions ", and it quickly started a debate. I did not want to continue this on the other thread, as it had little to do with the OP's direction on his thread. What say you, Geoff, George, Almarq, Ralph, anybody......if this thread goes nowhere, I can always have it removed. Enjoy ! MrD.
mrdecibel

Showing 1 response by atmasphere

Here's the problem: All electronics make significant distortion, even though on paper it looks 'low'. But what is on paper is pretty much the Emperor's New Clothes.
However, the ear has a masking principle and in audio its sort of come to our rescue. Solid state amps make considerably less distortion than tube amps but tubes are still around because solid state is harsh. This harshness is caused by higher ordered harmonics. The thing is, there is less distortion in the solid state amp than in a tube amp, but in a tube amp there are also more lower ordered harmonics- in particular the 2nd and/or 3rd (our amps favor the 3rd, which is treated by the ear very much the way it does the second).


The presence of the lower ordered harmonics masks the presence of the higher ordered harmonics. This is significant, because when masked the amp sounds smoother, even though it has more distortion. The funny thing is that it can also sound more detailed and have a deeper wider soundstage- and this is directly on account of the higher distortion! So what is happening is the lower orders are helping the otherwise high distortion amps to sound more real- and the ear's masking principle has a lot to do with it.

Now the other bit is that the ear is keenly sensitive to higher ordered harmonics. The reason is we use them rather than the fundamental tones to sense sound pressure. So the ear **has** to be sensitive in this regard. The fact of the masking principle is what makes *any* sort of electronics listenable.