Better amp or better tubes?


With this lockdown I'm finding myself and I'm sure many others listening to music more often and with that my mind has gone into upgrade mode.
My amp is a rare Quickilver 300B that must be at least 25 years old using genalax gold lion  300b tubes.
Over a year ago I sent an email to Mike sanders asking him about suggesting upgrades to the unit and surprisingly he told me if the amp is working fine to just leave it alone. We ok then.
The genalax 300b are modest in price  costing about $300 a pair and have worked flawlessly. If I were to upgrade the tubes, what direction would you suggest? To be honest, I'm a bit apprehensive in spending a lot for tubes since they can fail at anytime. Am I being overly concerned?

So, do I upgrade the tubes or amp? Amp budget of under 4k.

Thanks


emil

Showing 1 response by elliottbnewcombjr

I have battleships from the 60’s, they are awesome, 25 years is young for the equipment, but a long time for tubes. And, the old stuff has lots of room and access to repair/replace anything in the future, the newer stuff is crowded inside.

1. re-bias existing tubes, assistance from Quicksilver, listen, any change?

2. I would definitely try new tubes. I have read a few articles that indicate NOS is not always best as assumed. I would try less costly version, DON"T LISTEN TO THEM. break them in 60 hours (don’t need to listen, just leave them on, walk away). Break in is a real thing, avoid a bad first impression prior to break in.

3. Then, put originals back in, listen to compare with new.

4. Verify with Quicksilver how to bias the new replacements in case some minor difference might effect things (probably the same, just eliminating any potential for a false comparison)

5. Listen to new. Nirvana re-discovered?
.........................................

Brent Jesse is a terrific source.

http://www.audiotubes.com/audtube.htm#aud%20list

NOS WE $3,100. each, based on rarity.

New current JJ $150. each, constructed like WE, ceramic base which I like.

I would buy matched JJ’s, and,see what change.

Then, if you have decided to keep the amps, and you have deep pockets, and have to know, Brent will let you return the JJ and buy the horribly expensive NOS. Confirm that with him ahead of time, if NOS not better than JJ, I would switch back.

Other member said "a 300B is a 300B". I certainly found that not to be true

my recent 6SL7 replacement. Original Cayin brand, unknown maker, sounded terrific. One side tube went bad. I have 2 tube testers. I had good used GE in stock, put it in, wonderful together with the used Cayin,

So, let’s get a new matched set. Picked Sylvania 6SL7WGT military from Brent: nooo! original used Cayin and used GE definitely preferred. Brent let me finish breaking them in (they did change a bit, which is why I advise breaking new tubes in first before listening.),

and eventually switch them for a matched pair of GE’s like my used one. (I got 2 matched pairs in case I live that long), at half the price, and Brent refunded the difference.
.......................................

And, I was using 6550’s, liked them, just for fun tried KT88’s. I prefer the KT88’s slightly.