Aball, thanks for posting the results of your experiment. You've found a good place to be in your enjoyment of just a single format! One thought on your methodology, however: you might find that you begin to notice the difference between vinyl and CD more readily if you do more long term listening with just one format, not switch rapidly back and forth. I.e., live with listening to vinyl-only for a week. Then play some of the same music on CD and see what reaction you have.
Cheers,
Cheers,