I was raised on radio and records. When the CD and digital music came about in the early to mid 80s, I went forward with that and never looked back. I get that the turntable and records can, together, can constitute a musical experience (especially for old guys like me) but don't kid yourself into thinking that analog music reproduction can ever compete with Redbook or better.Similar experience to me, with one exception. I flogged all my LPs in the early 90s and went for CD. Started well (if one ignores the extra money I could not afford) but I did have some vexing experiences with CD, especially reissues. A classic example was The Rite of Spring on DG - Claudio Abbado conducting the LSO. It was lifeless. It took until about 2010 when I twigged - these companies, even reputable ones like DG, have to make money and reissues of the (then) new format are one way to make a buck. Unfortunately even more money can be saved by not allowing for the change of format in the reissue process. Net result: original vinyl superior to CD, often substantially so. I got on the vinyl revival bandwagon and by then I had sufficient money to afford decent gear. I presently run a digital system and a vinyl rig. When I am in bad company (ie alone) I play my digital rig. When I am in good company it is always the vinyl rig that gets a workout - more fun, more involving, and in about - say - 3/4 of the comparisons where it is vinyl vs digital the vinyl wins out, despite a more expensive digital rig.
So my turntable ownership since around 1991 is zero. Just like film...some want it to still be better...but it just can't be.
If cheap vs cheap - you will get crap vinyl and good digital. If midprice vs midprice the gap closes but I would still prefer digital. If pushing it towards the high end (where I am at) then vinyl is superior. By way of example of my level I run a Pass Labs X150.8 power amp. Other gear is around that level. I believe if one went for really high-end gear the the preference for the analogue sound would widen.
All this is one factor. Another factor is how much work are you prepared to put in. If you are mildly anal and take fastidious care with setup (cleaning, azimuth, VTA, SRA, Tracking Force, cleaning, Bias, and more cleaning) and several other things I could mention then even a midrange vinyl system has the (and I apologize for the abstract adjectives) analogue, warm, inviting sound.
Not a perfect analogy but there is some similarity with the equally interesting valve vs SS debate. The numbers are with the transistors, but the smiles are with the tubes!