SF Guarneri Homage vs Harbeth 7ES3


I am considering either one of these two speakers. A used Guarneri does not cost much more than a new Harbeth 7ES3. I listen to a lot of Jazz, vocal, strings, country. All of my electronics is EAR (except for a Shindo preamp). Any recommendations from people who've tried both? Thanks.
ggavetti
Ggavetti, I own the SF G's and have listened extensively to the 7Es3's.... Really 'like comparing apples and oranges' as the old saying goes.
If you listen to Jazz and vocal and strings, IMHO the G's are just about unbeatable and frankly to me in a different league to the Harbeths. Harbeth's are very good and have a " BBC" sound. I like this sound, BUT again IMHO it is a coloration. You can also hear the contribution of the box with the Harbeths.
EAR make good electronics and will match well with either speaker. In the end, the best advice I can give you is to go out and see if you can hear both speakers for yourself.
I would offer a different thought on the issue of sound coloration contributed by the speaker cabinet particularly in the Harbeth line of speakers. Every speaker will be colored to some extent with the box contributing to the coloration. In the case of Harbeth, they have adopted "thin-wall" removable front and back panels in order to create a low coloration, low inertia and low energy storage cabinet in true BBC tradition. The cabinet is sometimes called a "lossy" cabinet due to this design approach and is one of Harbeth's secret for natural sound reproduction(they also use their own proprietary Radial driver designed and built in-house in the Harbeth factory).

Like Daveyf has mentioned, it's really like comparing apples and oranges. I do not have experience with the Guarneri Homage but have listened to the lower range models in the Cremona line and owned the Grand Pianos. My experience with Harbeth speakers were the Monitor 30, Super HL-5 and Compact 7ES-3. To my ears, the Sonus Fabers are more colored than the Harbeth. Maybe the Guarneri is less colored and steer more towards neutrality. I share the same notion in that it is best the person listens to both speakers before deciding himself. Both speakers will sound substantially different from one another and listening preferences will determine which speaker would match one's taste more. The Guarneri Homage costs substantially higher than the Compact 7ES-3 and the build quality on the former is miles ahead in comparison to the plain ole' British boxes, a testament of exquisite Italian craftmanship at its finest. Both are great speakers by the way.
Just to clarify: I listened to the speakers but at dealers, therefore with different electronics, which makes it hard to make a real comparison. So, my hope was to find people who tried them both with comparable electronics.
Maybe a good way to describe the Guarneri's would be...a richly detailed sound. They are very resolving speakers....certainly on a different level of performance then the lower level Sonus Faber speakers.