What innovative, unconventional cartridge designs can you recommend?


Most cartridges have a stylus and cantilever where the transducer (magnet, iron or coil) sits on the far end of the cantilever.  What other designs are there?

I am mindful of two designs which put the business end right on top of the stylus.  The first is the moving coil (MC) Audio Technica AT-ART1000 which places two tiny coils, each 0.9-mm diameter, with eight turns of wire directly above the stylus.  Australian price is about AUD-7000 and there apparently is a newer model, slightly less exxe. the ART1000X.  This has square coils for a bit more output, and threaded mounting holes.

A downside is that stylus replacement involves a factory maintenance program and the Australian website page describing this service does not exist.

Another design is optical, exemplified by DS Audio's range.  While these still need a stylus to trace the groove, the signal is produced by reading the intensity of light produced by a Light Emitting Diode (LED) hitting two sensors.  Between the LED and the sensors are two 'shades' mounted above the stylus which change the amount of light as the stylus vibrates.  These cartridges need a special "photo-stage" to replace the conventional phono-stage which is an additional expense.

Australian prices including photo-stages range from AUD-2,150 for the DS-E1 to the DS Master 3 at approximately AUD-40,800, which is a bit outside my price range!  Where is the sweet spot?

What other way-out designs are there?

richardbrand

@pindac If I understand you correctly, you are questioning whether stylus and cantilever can affect the sound of an optical cartridge?

From the tip of the stylus to the point on the cantilever where the transducer mechanism sits* all that we have are mechanical vibrations being transmitted with greater or lesser fidelity. Then the transducer creates an electrical signal from the mechanical vibration. Surely, whatever kind of transducer is used, the most complete, accurate and faithful representation of the groove will be desirable? So does it not seem correct that a stiffer, or lighter cantilever, a better suspension, and a stylus capable of tracking every little wiggle of the groove is going to make a difference to any of those transducer mechanisms?

*be it a coil, a magnet, a chunk of iron, a shade plate or a strain gauge

Photon - Shadow - Electron - Electrical Impulse. ( Materials used for overall structure are copied from an alternate technology and are only used to mimic the designs from that technology - One Brands has done extensive R&D and really knows the value if what is selected. Or has the approach been to adopt matwerials without fully understanding their value. Modifying the materials to suit the interface to suit other parts belonging to the alternate technology??)

Coil - Magnet - Electromagnetic Induction - Electrical Impulse. (Materials used for overall Structure very very well known. Multiple Brands have extensive R&D and knows what is to be selected)

Again another contributor with no substantiation only conjecture to attempt to answer the inquiry being made.

For the record, I am not saying a DS Audio Cart' should be avoided, I am saying why does a modern design Optical Read Cart', need a Diamond Cantilever or other materials renowned for being exceptional when used as conduits for managing transferred kinetic energy.       

@dogberry 

We are wasting our time. Pinman thunks the DS Audio cartridge could use a rusty nail or a wooden toothpick for a cantilever and it wouldn’t sound any different. 

@pindac 

Someone will be much much better for explaining why Sputtered Titanium is seen to be the most optimal for creating a Form that will be beneficial to a Optical Read of a Shadow????  

Nobody except you just now has mentioned sputtered titanium, and certainly not in the context of DS Audio optical cartridges which exclusively use aluminium alloys for their bodies.  (They do have mono cartridges which incorporate a brass footer).

In fact, you were the first to mention titanium in this context.  There is a world of difference between sputtering, in which material is randomly sprayed at a surface, and laser fusion which precisely sinters particles together in 3-d space, a bit like 3-d printing.

why does a modern design Optical Read Cart', need a Diamond Cantilever or other materials renowned for being exceptional when used as conduits for managing transferred kinetic energy

In your terms, the "Shadow" being "Read" is created by a shade plate attached to the cantilever as described by @dogberry.  You can see pictures here DS Audio - please scroll down to Details

Kinetic energy is transmitted to the shade plate, which makes it move relative to the cartridge body.  Ideally it moves precisely in synchronicity with the stylus, which ideally tracks precisely the modulations in the groove.  As a purely mechanical system up to this point, it is subject to stresses and strains.  Stresses are forces, and strains the deformations always caused by those stresses. Acceleration of the stylus can be huge, reaching thousands of Gs where G is the acceleration caused by gravity at the earth's surface.  Materials and mechanical design influence how well the shade plate actually moves with the stylus, and how well the stylus actually responds to the groove.

Mechanical systems are also subject to vibrations and resonances.  Cartridges, if designed to be neutral, channel these vibrations away from the stylus / body interface.  Many cartridges are not designed to be neutral, but to add pleasing colourations of their own.  If that is what you want, DS Audio is probably not for you, but I digress.

So now, we have a shade plate which moves. From this point on you can forget about energy transfer altogether, because the energy of the light source comes from an external DC power supply, not from the record.  One of the functions of the Equalizer is to provide clean DC power.

As the shade plate moves, the shadow it casts on the photoreceptor changes in area, varying the number of photons absorbed and hence modulating the output signal, which varies with the position of the shade plate and not its acceleration.

This is a slight simplification because in current DS Audio stereo cartridges, there are two light sources and two photoreceptors, plus one shade plate with two "wings".

How does the DC power get from the Equalizer to the diodes in the cartridge?  A cunning 'steal' from conventional cartridge wiring design, which uses four separate wires, allowing each channel to be balanced.  Most phono inputs are not balanced however, so DS Audio use two of the wires to carry DC and neutral.

I believe DS Audio is working on cabling to carry balanced cartridge output and power, but this will likely require tonearms to be rewired or custom designed.

@pindac

DS Audio is not the only high-end cartridge maker to offer a variety of cantilever constructions.  The LOMC Wilson Benesch Tessellate I referenced earlier offers boron, sapphire and diamond:

The hybrid needle carrier is available in a variety of materials, including boron, sapphire and diamond. Each material offers unique properties that contribute to the overall performance and sound quality of the cartridge