Turntable, tonearm, cartridge setup is really complicated. But once done right it is almost heaven.
Please, I have sat as you have and listened to digital music, was almost at peace with the world and the CD skipped or didn't track correctly, etc. So, equipment issues occur no matter the format.
As others have mentioned, I'm thinking that turntable, tonearm cartridge setup you have may have contributed to this issue. I've never experienced an auto lift system that when a pop happens, it lifts the arm. wow! but okay, it is what it is.
But, if you really appreciate digital and don't feel you are missing anything with digital, then enjoy.
Some people ask about your setup to discriminate or to determine if you have a piece of equipment that may not be quite up to snuff.
You know. If you didn't spend $80,000 for a turntable, tonearm, cartridge setup then you aren't in the same league with them and well, that is why.... not true at all but that is what some feel.
Simple systems with the right music would bring out the emotions in me.
It is a big deal with analog systems. But once set up correctly, well... heaven (almost).
anyway, enjoy