2. tech-talk
  3. 174009-97086

Orientation... Gable roof.... best set up for acoustics on long or short wall?

I would appreciate your thoughts... we are building a house with a large gabled room above the garage to be our music room. The total dimension is 39' long 24' wide and 15' high at the ridge line of the gable. The slopes of the gable end at a 3' knee wall on the long sides with two 10' dormers opposite each other on the long walls. Picture a tent with two dormers on the sides. One end of the gable wall will have a window and the other end will have the stairs leading up from the garage and will have a bathroom and bar area at that end as well. 

This will leave a listening/music room area of 29'x24'. The ridge line is running down the center of the long dimension.

The listening area choices are:

1. setting up church style with the 24' width being constant and the seating from the end gable wall where the speakers are located would be roughly 20' (with flexibility to move forward or back for best sound). The two 10' gables would then open up on the left and right long walls as you face the speakers roughly at the listening area.

2. setting up the other direction facing a dormer in the front and one behind. On either side of the dormer the roof line would rise from the 3' nee wall to the center ridge line to 15' at the apex, then slope back down the other side. In this orientation the width would be 29' and the listening area would be around 16' from the front wall, again with some flexibility to move forward or backward. 

So really it is a choice of having the slanted walls on the side in the first case and  front and behind in the second scenario. Which way do you think would sound the best? 

I tried to attach a picture (rendering) but could not figure out how to make it happen. 

Much appreciated.

montbren
artemus_5's avatar
artemus_5
1,911 posts
 

OK Nice. The picture helps.. First, the ridge height on a 24 ft run with a 12/12 pitch will be somewhere around 12ft, not 15. But that is of little consequence for the room. However the 3 ft knee wall will come in appx 3 ft on each side so that cuts down the room from 24 to 18ft. Still not a bad size. Plus there will be another 3 ft in from the knee wall to get a 6 ft ceiling height. Still not bad. You still end up with an 18 x 29 space. Also these are approximate numbers but still pretty close

Now to the dormers. 10 ft on each side will make a space of 10 x 24. across. This is going to throw a kink in firing longways IMO. However I’m not sure that firing across is any better. There are ways to get it better but it involves design changes. And that may not be possible if you have already started or if the house is already built. I think you are going to have to experiment with setup

montbren OP
7 posts
 

The ridge run will be 39' with 10' of that run taken up with a bathroom and bar/cabana area below. So leaving roughly 29' long x 24' wide room for listening. I appreciate your perception given your long experience in building. I hope I have described things correctly. Best wishes.

montbren OP
7 posts
 

I think your 18'x29' estimate, with the 10x24 blow outs for the dormers on each side makes sense given the considerations that you mentioned. Thanks again.

montbren OP
7 posts
 

Here is the front view of the garage with music room above.https://onedrive.live.com/?cid=122FBA21411877E2&id=122FBA21411877E2%2157271&parId=122FBA21411877E2%2157269&o=OneUp

ghdprentice
6,354 posts
 

Nice place. I would start with listening direction on axis with the crest of the roof. I would not think having the reflections on the ceiling behind you a good thing acoustically. Hopefully it also allows you to pull the speakers out further from the wall as well. 

 

So what is your equipment. Big horns, full sized standing speakers, stand mount? Electronics?

More to discover