I did not mean to suggest that Peter is the “last word” if such a thing exists. He is however an authority and I mentioned him only because I happen to have one of his cartridges with a ruby cantilever. I did not buy it for the cantilever. Nor did I buy it for ease of stylus and cantilever replacement. That was not the topic of your thread. I prefer originals as well.
To me tracking ability is more than staying in the groove of a warped record. It is all about responding to the modulations within the grooves. I believe stylus, suspension and compliance are more important in this regard.
My original reply to your thread was a reaction to the different physical properties of minerals used to make the cantilevers, the short stiff posts. My opinion is this difference is way down the list of what makes a good cartridge. You are emphasizing that it is a new pipe construction which to me is a different issue. Fine.
You have more knowledge and experience with cartridges than I, so I defer. However I doubt that you organize and rate your fifty transducers based on which mineral is used to construct the cantilever. This is the point I was trying to make.
Finally, why is it currently impossible to make the vintage type of cantilevers that you admire? Seems odd to me.
All the best.
To me tracking ability is more than staying in the groove of a warped record. It is all about responding to the modulations within the grooves. I believe stylus, suspension and compliance are more important in this regard.
My original reply to your thread was a reaction to the different physical properties of minerals used to make the cantilevers, the short stiff posts. My opinion is this difference is way down the list of what makes a good cartridge. You are emphasizing that it is a new pipe construction which to me is a different issue. Fine.
You have more knowledge and experience with cartridges than I, so I defer. However I doubt that you organize and rate your fifty transducers based on which mineral is used to construct the cantilever. This is the point I was trying to make.
Finally, why is it currently impossible to make the vintage type of cantilevers that you admire? Seems odd to me.
All the best.