Well Tempered/CROFT/Harbeth...London SG or NAGAOKA


This system has performed very nicely with my Charisma Denon 103.... However, I don't want to keep borrowing my Step Up and 0.5 meter Interconnect from my main system. So I'm leaning toward a HO/MM to simplify and get this setup up and running on it's own. The synergy between the London and CROFT phono is well documented... And as many know, they like damped arms, so the SG should perform well with the Amadeus. The London SG retails at around $1,200 US. Enter Nagaoka... I believe the NEW Well Tempered MM is actually a modified Nagaoka, but based on it's price, it may haven begun life as a 150 or 200.  I'd likely go a bit higher up the line to a 300 or 500 series. The London seems like the way to go, but I do have concerns about the whole no Cantilever thing. I guess these are not for the faint of heart, as they say. Then of course, I don't want to sell the Nagaoka short. I like what I've heard about these, and they seem to fall in to the more full bodied, and not Hi-Fi or exaggerated camp. The London, I'm not so sure as they say these are so alive and open sounding. That may not be a bad thing, as long as they are not crude or etched in any way. Thanks in advance!
fjn04
You may want to check out Raul's very long thread about MM cartridges. He started it 1-15-2008 and it's still pretty active. Raul liked the Nagaoka 50 super. Not sure how the 500 compares to that. 
Nagaoka is one of the biggest cartridge manufacturer, the WT cart is Nagaoka OEM work. Retail is $800, not sure what is special about it, but if the cantilever is not boron and the stylus is not line contact type then it's a rip off. 

For the same money you can find state of the art MM cartridge like Audio-Technica AT-ML170 or some nice Grace (depends on the model). You will find many info about those carts in the recommended thread. Simply ignore the fact that the author of that nice MM thread prefers digital and lomc now (who cares?). 

In my opinion AT-ML170 and for example Grace Level II BR/MR are the best MM ever made. What is important for your arm is the compliance of the cartridge. AT is mid compliance, Grace is high compliance. 

Your Denon is very low compliance, but make sure to convert 100hz (japan standard) compliance to 10hz compliance. 





@fnj04 "When she was good, she was very, very good, but when she was bad, she was horrid." The Decca SG can be utterly superb as long as the vinyl is in good condition. Surface noise is more obvious but dynamics are startlingly real and present. On the rare occasion the vinyl is rough, I switch to an older Ortofon HOMC. If I replay the same disk with the Decca, I ask why I bothered with the other cartridge. Yes, the Decca is noisier but it captures the music in a more palpable way. Think of it as a small price to pay for a clearer insight into the emotion of the music. Female voice is to die for. If you like the Decca, you can send it to John Wright to change the tip to a paratrace diamond for more refinement and detail. Or you can play it safe and get the Nagaoka MP500.