I see digital as inherently more precise in that vinyl results can vary much more widely I think.
I was under the impression of all things being equal. IOW, the best analog system and record, along with the best CD and player. Still a digital system can have a sonic characteristic that's not natural. I had a Luxman CD player years back that could not make anything sound real. Also a couple of other brands of CD players, or DAC's. I've heard plenty of bad sounding records, but they still somewhat sound more like the original source, than a bad sounding digital reproduction. After hearing some fairly bad digital reproductions, I find that I still hear that artificial reproduction in some pricey players. With analog, I never get fatigue, or those odd artifacts even from the worst records I've had. Bringing tolerances into it changes it some, but still I think vinyl has the edge.