What were your own blind cable test results?


Did you ever conduct a blind speaker cable test yourself? Please share your experiences, results, and the gear level associated with your test. For example, test conducted with cable types: DIY, Lo/Mid/High end, Components: Lo-Fi, Mid-Fi, High End-Fi. Feel free to elaborate on your gears if you like.

Please note that this is not a debate on whether DIY, or cheaper cable makes a big difference with high end cables. Nor about snake oils, etc.

I'll start first, a buddy of mine and I did a recent test on our Mid-Fi system with 5 cables, 1 Home Depot, 1 DIY, 3 Mid End cables from various cable Co. After 2 hours of listening and swapping cables, our results - it was very difficult to tell. The longer you listen, the more fused the music becomes, perhaps of listening fatigue. However, we were able to pick out one branded cable consistently as it has a 'flattening' effect on the music in our system, funny that this cable contains the most high-tech approach. As far as the other four cables, it was very difficult to discern the difference. This exercise helped us to weed out the one that we dislike the most, and enjoy the music with the others.
springowl

Showing 1 response by shadorne

Springowl,

A lot depends on the speaker impedance and the amp output impedance. Amps with low output impedance will modify the transfer function as the speaker load varies with frequency. This can become audible when the speaker load vary significantly, as more voltage drop occurs across the amp output stage when the speaker impedance is very low.

For example, imagine the amp ouput impedance is 4 Ohms. The Speaker impedance varies between 16 ohms at 60 Hz (driver/box resonance) and 3 ohms at 2 KHZ. The speaker frequency response is perfectly flat.

The drop across the output impedance of the amp means that the music at 60 Hz is roughly two and four tenths times GREATER than it should be compared to music at 2 KHz (in order to sound flat). This is enough to be clearly audible. It will sound like bass bloom at the woofer resonance frequency.

Now throw in a cable with a high resistance and you will alter the transfer function again.

A 1 ohm cable will mean that the amplifier sees 17 ohms at 60 hz and 4 ohms at 2 Khz.

The music at 60 Hz will now be one and nine tenths greater then at 2 Khz....a small but not insignificant change.

In contrast, a speaker with a perfectly flat impedance response and flat frequency response will sound the same at both frequenies when driven by the amp with 4 ohm output impedance.

In contrast, an amplifier with low output impedance (less than 0.1 ohm) will sound the same at both frequenies even with the speaker that has a highly variable impedance response with frequency (3 Ohms at 2 Khz and 16 Ohms at 60 Hz).

So what does this mean? It means the audible effect is determined by the cable AND the equipment it is connecting.

In some cases a different cable will not make any difference and in other cases it will indeed make a subtle difference. Therefore it is incorrect to attribute the change (or lack of change) in sound (bass bloom in this case) to the cable alone! The same speaker cable may do nothing for one person and yet make a subtle difference for another....all dependent on the gear it connects.