A bit of an odd-ball question but I am intrigued. There are many good responses here first of all. I'm not a vinyl nut but do own a turntable and do listen to Zep. I never though of "tuning" my TT to a specific genre of music but it is interesting. I would guess the cartridge would be the player here and there are many options. My set up is a newer Denon fully auto TT (laziness) mated with a Denon MC cartridge. I'm happy with the sound. The idea I think is extract as much as you can from the grooves, then you'll get the groove.
What is best turntable for listening to Rock from the sixties like Led Zeppelin?
The sound quality isn’t great, so rather than something super revealing, something that is very musical, and can also convey the magic. Sort of the Decca cartridge equivalent of turntables. I am guessing less Caliburn and Techdas, more Linn, Roksan, Denon, EMT 927, Rega, even.