What are your TWO favorite Symphonic Recordings?


Only one would cruel and unusual punishment.

My first would be Joseph Krips 1958 recording of Schubert's 9th on London with the London SO.There was a CD of it as well
which is also OP I believe. If you can find either it or the record at anything under a $1OO its a good buy. Personally
I would give 2K for one if I didn't have a copy.
More than once I've read a critic claim this was the greatest record ever made. The LSO was at the top of its game and gave
this uber- powerful symphony a power-house performance.

My second is the 1976 recording of the Brahms 2nd by James Levine and the Chicago SO in the acoustically wonderful Medina Temple in Chicago. Originally it was on RCA but can be had on Amazon as part of Sony Classical 3 disc set of all Brahm'4 symphonies and his great masterpiece the "German Requiem" for less than 15 bucks ! Very nice sound as well.
Levine does a near-miracle in capturing the 2nd Symphonys combo of power , lyricism and harmonic stability all at the same time.
Of all the great Romantic composers Brahms was the most learned, he literally had the music of 4 centuries at his fingertips, knew every note of Bach, Mozart, Schubert and Beethoven. It took me 30 years of listening before I really
got a glimmer of just how great he is.

A few words of Brahms on Schubert;

"Where else is there a genius like his,that soars with such
boldness and certainty ...he is a child of the Gods...who plays in a region and at a height to which others can by no means attain .
schubert

Showing 3 responses by almarg

Nice thread idea, Schubert. My two, in no particular order:

-- Brahms Symphony No. 1, Toscanini/NBC Symphony, recorded in 1940. My favorite performance of my favorite symphony. Can be listened to or downloaded here. The primitive mono sound doesn't matter, although it is surprisingly listenable.

-- Dvorak Symphony No. 9, "From The New World," Horenstein/Royal Philharmonic Orchestra, Chesky CD31. Recorded in 1962, engineering by Kenneth Wilkinson. Great music, great performance, and probably the best sounding symphonic recording I have ever heard. Those who disdain the CD medium should hear this.

Best regards,
-- Al
Frogman, thanks very much for alerting us to the Schubert festival at Bard. I've just purchased tickets to the 8/17 1:30 p.m. performances of the D.959 sonata, various songs, and the D.951 piano duet. Albeit at the presumably lesser hall, Olin, but being able to take in the scenery during daytime drives to and from the area was a factor in that choice. (It's about an 80 mile trip for me from here in CT, btw).

Schubert, I too have and love the immortal 1947 performance of the Alto Rhapsody by Kathleen Ferrier, Clemens Krauss conducting the LPO, on an imported Decca LP I purchased during the 1980s.

Best regards,
-- Al
From the Wikipedia writeup on Kathleen Ferrier:
The opera critic Rupert Christiansen, writing as the 50th anniversary of Ferrier's death approached, maintained that "no singer in this country [the UK] has ever been more deeply loved, as much for the person she was as for the voice she uttered." Her death, he continued, "quite literally shattered the euphoria of the Coronation" (which had taken place on 2 June 1953). Ian Jack, editor of Granta, believed that she "may well have been the most celebrated woman in Britain after the Queen." Among the many tributes from her colleagues, that of Bruno Walter has been highlighted by biographers: "The greatest thing in music in my life has been to have known Kathleen Ferrier and Gustav Mahler—in that order." Very few singers, Lord Harewood writes, "have earned so powerful a valedictory from so senior a colleague." At a memorial service at Southwark Cathedral on 14 November 1953 the Bishop of Croydon, in his eulogy, said of Ferrier's voice: "She seemed to bring into this world a radiance from another world."

From time to time commentators have speculated on the directions Ferrier's career might have taken had she lived.... Christiansen further suggests that, given the changes of style over the past 50 years, Ferrier might have been less successful in the 21st century world: "We dislike low-lying voices, for one thing — contraltos now sound freakish and headmistressy, and even the majority of mezzo-sopranos should more accurately be categorised as almost-sopranos." However, she was "a singer of, and for, her time — a time of grief and weariness, national self-respect and a belief in human nobility." In this context "her artistry stands upright, austere, unfussy, fundamental and sincere."
Best regards,
-- Al