Universal player or DAC?


Hi,

I have a 2003-era Music Hall CD25. It has digital outputs, so I am considering adding a Schiit Bifrost Uber, or replacing the CDP with an Oppo BDP-103. Will the Oppo make enough of a difference in redbook CD playback, or is a dedicated DAC such as Schiit or a used Benchmark a better option? Of course, there is the added bonus of video and SACD playback with the Oppo.

I have a large collection of CDs and vinyl, and I don't plan on doing a music server thing just yet. Give me inconvenience or give me death!

Thanks,

paul
paulburnett

Showing 1 response by chrisr

If the Oppo does down sample blu ray audio through its digital output, then I would not get an external DAC.
I just compared a yamaha player s-677 through its analog output against my MSB DAC Link III through digital, and the yamaha is better on cd (less digititis, more natural stereo separation), and much much better with blu-ray discs (no downsampling/software protection). Plus it plays sacd.
That made me realize that DAC chips/output stages and their implementation are so much better nowadays, especially in an Oppo, even in a yamaha (cheap burr brown 5102), that it must be hard to get "better" with an external dac. You would get a different sound certainly, but then in that case I would compare good players (oppo, marantz and others), pick the one you like and forget about outboard DACs.