Time To Impose Minimum Standards for LP's


Many Audiogon Members have invested substantial sums in acquiring high-end Turntables, Tonearms, and Cartridges. It seems appropriate that sellers of vinyl records should consider that fact before they list records for sale. Damaged records are not playable, IMO, on any Audiophile Turntable. Personally, I will not play a record that is a "7 out of 10" on the Audiogon scale. Nor will I resell such a record. It is destined for the round file in the corner. Yet today on Audiogon there are records offered which are rated at "3 out of 10" and which are described as damaged but "too good to throw away". Please save the junk for some other venue, or yardsale. Perhaps it's time for Audiogon to impose minimum standards for Sellers of music. Because the listing is free is not a legitimate reason to offer junk on this site.
commcat

Showing 2 responses by ferrari

Make no mistake, finding good playable vinyl today is a daunting task to say the least. Some of you know me as a reseller of vinyl here on Audiogon. Been doing so for many years now. I am one of the few if not the only one that test plays each album that comes in and base my grading of it quite simply. If I would keep it for my own library or not, based upon its playback condition. If it passes my standard then it is offered for auction or classified resale. All my auctions are $1.00 no reserve. To my mind this is the fairest was of marketing to the Audiogon membership. And yes on a occassion some LPs have sold just for a $1.00. But, hey its an auction, so no complaints on my end.

I deal first and foremost with jazz Lps from the 50,s to current day. But mostly 50,s , 60,s , and 70,s. Most of those in that period of time were small independent labels, such as Riverside, Prestige, Emarcy, Blue Note, Jazzland, etc. None of the companies had the resources to press huge quantities. A pressing of say 50,000 would have bankrupt many of them. Fast foward to today some 40 to 50 years down the road original issues of these in playable condition dwindle each year. Great vintage vinyl is finite and only so much of it remains. The day of good used cheap vinyl is long gone.

I do not visual grade any vinyl LP. For instance I have a Dave Brubeck LP Red,Hot and Cool. Mono pressing from 1955 I think. Visually the LP looks just terrible and something that should be thrown on the scrap heap. However to my surprise, it plays without flaw, surface noise is damn near zero. But I dare not resale the LP, because the end users would crucify me for what I sent him.

Grading systems are subjective at best, based upon the sellers integrity. I buy as well and it becomes more difficult each day to find great vintage vinyl. However on my end I try as much as possible to take the guess work out of the equation.
I said one of the few if not the only one that test plays each and every Lp I get in. I read a lot of ads here on Audiogon and can't remember the last vinyl reseller that test plays the LPs. I don't sell a bunch, because of the time involved in test playing and most reseller here are into it for the Benjamins for the most part. For me it is hobby first then business.

By the other side of the token, you should see what I get in here that was visually graded. Lately over 34 percent of the used I buy is sheer scrap.

Hell yes I will toot my own horn, worked my butt off to provide excellent LPs always at a $1.00 no reserve on auction plus provide the service to go along with each sale.