Greetings, I would add Musical Fidelity's top of the line players to your short list...Happy listening
16 responses Add your response
I will listen to the ones mentioned above.
I have just heard DV-60 in both regular and up sampling mode.
Three player had upsampling: EMM, dCS and now Esoteric; I always preferred to listen to those in upsampling mode, in which they always had more separation between the instruments thus sounding more "open", that really helps me to keep tracks of all the instrument in a section when they all play simultaneously.
Does something like that exists? A player that can delivery enough seperation for all 7,8 instruments to sound clearly at the same time.
Does something like that exists? A player that can delivery enough seperation for all 7,8 instruments to sound clearly at the same time.If the rest of your system allows it to, yes. If it's revealing, unyieldingly analytical you're looking for, you might get better results with suggestions for an entire system, rather than just the CD player. Because even the most revealing CD player will be censored by speakers that are not so...and most aren't, IMO.
As for CD player, I think these fit your description:
The rest of the chain should follow in kind, if that's the sound you're wanting. If you decide you want such input, please tell us the size of the room, music preferences, full range/monitors, SS or tubes, access to dealers for auditions, etc.
Yes, Boa, you are right. I do need an entire system that’s analytical/revealing. I am in market for a compatible preamp, most likely a SS, and a specific brand of XLR cables that are equally shameless.
Since I got rid of my last set up, Avalon acoustic/Jadis - which was not the type of analytical system I enjoy, I bought two pairs of Adam professional Audio speakers self powered. I am driving them with nothing good, but I am still much happier then I was before.
These speakers were quite revealing to my ears, I am pretty happy with them. A couple of dealers suggested that I was really looking for “studio sound”…which could be true; I am a “retired” musician.
I listen to my music in a 16x20 room with 20ft ceiling, it’s untreated, and the volume I listen to my music is embarrassingly low. I placed the speaker about a 1.5 ft from the wall and 4 ft apart (between the tweeters). I usually sit about 4-5 ft away from the speakers…near field listening.
The music I am concerned/enjoy the most are concertos (mostly piano) and symphonies, most of my collection are fast and well-organized-yet-congested pieces.
My budget is 15k for the source and preamp.
I live near playa del rey so I have access to all the LA dealers.
Although I don't consider it ruthlessly revealing, it is musically resolving and offers the purity of running direct to your powered amps. Perhaps a new APL NWO2, or for less money, an excellent APL Denon 3910. Run them straight to your Adam professional speakers. No preamp to get in the way of the pure signal you require.
I believe the APL NWO2 retails for around $15k, but considering you wouldn't require a preamp, it likely falls within your budget. The APL Denon 3910 retails for $6500 (last I checked).
Being a "retired" musician, I believe you'd appreciate these players.
Just a thought.
Considered a Cary Audio CD-306? It has been very well reviewed. I have not been able to compare mine with equivalent high-end CDP's apart from the Musical Fidelity kW. The Cary yields more detail and sounds more dynamic, but the MF sounds sweeter. That's on SACD.
If you are going to listen to RBCD only, I would recommend the Consonance Droplet. Half the price of the Cary, and has the Cary's measure in dynamics and imaging. Bass is more authoritative on the Droplet but can sound bloomy on the wrong tracks. If styling is important to you, IMO the Droplet kills the Cary for looks.
The other contender (which I have not had a chance to listen to) would be the Accuphase DP-78.
Following your last post, Trackmango, I'd ditto Tvad's recommendation of the APL NWO2. Source and preamp in one. I heard the previous iteration (NW01) play some Rachmaninov, and was overjoyed to actually hear each instrument remain distinct from the others, no matter how complex the music was. Not a hint of compression, or the blurring of one instrument into another, the player maintained a precise orchestration over the music itself in a way I've not heard in any other system.
Best of luck!
I was not able to find much information on these NWO players on APL's website (aplhifi.com I assume). What are the differences between NWO1, 2, 2,5?
Check the APLHiFi Discussion Forums for good info.
Here is info about the APLHiFi NWO1.
Here is a discussion about the APLHiFi NWO 2.5
You can also email Alex@aplhifi.com
APL is located in the Bay Area. For less than $150 round trip, you can fly there and hear the NWO2 at the APL facility. That's what I'd suggest.
There may be an owner in the LA area, but I'm not certain. I used to own an APL Denon 3910, but I have since sold it for financial reasons.
There may be an owner in the LA area, but I'm not certain. I used to own an APL Denon 3910, but I have since sold it for financial reasons.According to APL, there will soon be an LA-area owner willing to audition the NWO-2.5. I'm sure APL can give you more details.