The Frankensteining of Amplifiers


There is an Anthem Statement P2 on Audiogon right now. A really great amp that has garnered good reviews. This particular amp has had many parts replaced in an attempt to upgrade it: resistors caps, wiring etc. I assume that when an amp is initially designed and tested by ear the parts are purposefully chosen to reach a certain sound. Can we assume that replacing parts willy nilly will necessarily improve the sound? May it throw off a purposeful delicate balance of parts in an original design and create something much less than the original? Anyone have any experience with this?
jonhart
IMHO, it's not necessarily a good thing.  As an example, Da Hong Seetoo used to modify Jadis gear, and while he made it objectively better from a measurements standpoint, some of us felt that the mods robbed us of the Jadis house sound that we wanted.  I believe one of our members here on A-gon actually had the mods undone in a piece he had gotten.  Others, of course, liked the sound he created, so in large part it was a personal preference issue.

As another example, my prior speakers seemed like a good candidate for upgraded crossovers, so we built a standalone crossover box and put far better quality parts into that crossover.  However, the chokes we used were so much better that they had a different resistance value (even though they were rated the same) and it made the speakers unbearably bright.  Fortunately, the designer of the speakers was a member of our audio club, so he came over and redesigned the crossover to accommodate the new parts.  The end result was a much better-sounding speaker (to my ears), but it took a lot of work.

Ultimately, if someone has modified their gear, I'm sure they did it to sound better to them (and it indeed might sound better on an objective and subjective scale), but in that case I'd still want to hear it myself before buying it, because it may not necessarily sound the same as the brand name on the equipment.
No worries PC is a known and good modifier. Parts were not replaced willy nilly. The unit will sound better than stock. Well done and thought out upgrades always improve the sound of gear. The original units didn't use these better parts as they have cost constraints they must live under.

I am no engineer, so I leave that to the designer of the product, whether it be amps or speakers. I see all these posts about replacing caps, replacing this replacing that...I don't get it really. Something made you buy that amp or that pair of speakers. What made you buy it was the sound signature. That sound signiture, as you said, was built in by the the engineer of the product. That person most likely has a better trained ear than my 52 year old ears....I buy things because i think they sound good...and then I leave it alone. If I prefer a different sound, I sell it.