Should I add a DAC ?


Hi,

I have a Shanling CD-S100 cdp which is exactly the same as the Music Hall 25, these are the specs:

1. HDCD decoding chip
2. Burr-Brown 1732 24-bit/96kHz DAC
3. Philips CDM-12.1 transport controlled by a CD-7mkII servo
4. Thick brushed-aluminum front plate and solid chassis
5. Two digital outputs; 1 x coaxial and 1 x optical
6. Standard analog output
7. The OPA 2134 op amps are used for the output stage and low pass filtering
8. Full remote-control operation
9. High quality remote control
10. Easily readable and dimmable florescent display
11. Detachable power cord

Would adding a cheap DAC like the Channel Island Audio VDA-1 24/96 make an improvement ?

Thks,
foxtrot

Showing 1 response by mwilson

Bel Canto DAC 1.1 at under $600 will substantially improve the sound of that player - this is just one possibility. The above cost estimates for DACs to improve on the Music Hall don't match my experiences with that unit. I wouldn't expect most used DACs in the $400 or below range to do you much good, however - but a notch or two above that ($500-$750 even), you'll find several models that can substantially improve on its sound.

The CI in particular I would not worry about - you'd notice differences, but not all of them "better"... it's a nice unit, but very entry-level. I've owned it as well and would not recommend it to improve on your player.

Keep in mind, just because a DAC may have similar "hardware" (DAC chips etc.) as your player, its likely that its analog output stage is built to a higher standard as a standalone unit, and will be packing a better power supply etc. These differences can produce substantial performance gains.

The Music-Hall is a "giant-killer" to some degree, but I find that in their enthusiasm for the product, people can overstate that accolade. A decent mid-priced DAC can certainly help this unit achieve better performance.