Nic, either will do. Makes no difference.
35 responses Add your response
I don't have experience with either. But, I did extensively research resistors in advance of my Thiel crossover rebuild. Among all the subjective opinions I found (many here on Audiogon fora), everyone who heard Path Audio loved them. Dueland was almost as widely praised but a couple of people opined that Dueland, after long-term listening, wasn't necessarily better than, for example, Mills (which is what I ended up with).
I have used both extensively. The Path Audio are better in important ways. They are quieter meaning they reduce noise and are far more neutral sounding. Just so even handed top to bottom. The Duelund CAST resistors sound a tad tipped up in the presence region. The Path Audio resistors are a great choice!
Resistors definitely do make a difference. However, once you make the move from five for a dollar to the good ones then you are in the same boat with resistors as amps, speakers, cables, etc. In other words its a personal taste call. My suggestion would be buy one of each, find a place you can swap, and compare. Probably they will be different enough to hear but only in direct head to head. The only way to know for sure though is to compare.
I find the Duelund’s very very curious. They are deliberately temperature sensitive, which in the right place in the crossover could compensate somewhat for thermal compression in the driver. In the wrong place it could go the other way, and what happens if you don't have compression in the driver? This type of behavior is usually what we like to engineer out of our crossover.
I prefer to usue Mills for accuracy, thermal invariance, sound quality and small size for the wattage. They’ve always been glass smooth to my ears and good enough better compared to sand cast that I’ve not looked further.
So the way I found out about this, drove down to Oregon where my speaker's designer demo'd his new tweeter for me. It sounded great so I bought it. He said it requires a different crossover, which he showed me, and satisfied I could build it sent me home with the simple circuit diagram.
I went down to Radio Shack, bought the parts, put it all together, and called him up. This thing sounds nothing like what I heard at your place! It frankly sounds like crap! And no not "warm it up break it in" crap but "pure unadulterated never gonna get better crap." He asked me a few questions one of which was what parts did you use?
This was all years ago. Very hard to believe at this stage of my development. But, he must be right. I mean, everything else was the same. What else could it be?
Week or so later after swapping in the much more expensive parts wow, world of difference! Now sounds just like what I remembered hearing at his place.
What this proves:1. Auditory memory is a lot longer than some people think; and
2. Parts quality makes a lot more difference than some would have you believe.
Thank you Kenjit. I have built lord knows how many crossovers for dipole speakers. There is no where to hide the crossovers so I make them to look like art work. I chose the components that look the best. Good 1% resisters of the same value always sound the same. Once you get to 5% you might pick up a difference as it can get as high as 10 % between the two which is certainly audible.
I would not spend the extra money on Path Audio for the woofers. I would use the Mills MRA12 resistors in that position. They are also great and cost $5.That sounds like good advice to me, especially if budget is a constraint, but it may well be that upgrading the woofer resistors will also make audible improvements. I don't have experience with that but I did directly compare 160V and 250V versions of the same cap on my woofer boards (shunt caps, at that). It was a subtle thing, and some songs sounded pretty much identical thru either channel, but overall the thicker film channel sounded a touch more full, with increased ease of presentation, and a bit more bass heft/impact (most noticeable on kick drums and such).
What type of wiring do you recommendFWIW, I used Straightwire 18 ga solid on my new boards anywhere the cap or resistor leads were too short (or with foil-type coils which have no leads). But I used Cardas litz from the terminals to the boards and boards to the drivers (various gauge depending on input or output and woofer versus coax board). I made no attempt to sonically compare the Straightwire to anything else but did compare the Cardas to the OEM 18 ga solid (unknown source).
'Good 1% resisters of the same value always sound the same'
That's so sad. Some people are incapable of, or unwilling to hear the difference.
I can't directly answer the question but can tell you that Mills are smooth and way better than the cast 'white' monsters that sound bad anywhere they are used, especially in power supplies.
Mills are great for low-pass and as shunt resistors but I find them a little too smooth in series with mids or tweet. I have been experimenting with Powertron, a Vishay foil resistor which is vivid and displays fine detail and a brilliance that lights up the top end. This is not to be confused with brightness.
The Powertrons are rated at 3W or 30W when mounted on a heatsink.
I put psth audioon Everything for the bass picks up the most heat and the path keep the performance rock stable , and the Bsss stays tight and focused as long as the capacitors are not stocky Solen I am a big fan of the Clarity CSA caps for large values and I have been using Tonys sdvise ,Humble Homemade Hifi capacitor reviews the Cornell Dubilier 940C .01 uf 3000 c bypass caps work very well for a low cost way to make things uniform , Tony explained by using the very high 3000 v type their end caps conductor copper is much thicker .
he has been using them for years unless you want to use the a Duelund silver foil
for the teeeter which is slightly better still at $250 a Pr, vs $7. I get them atAllied
and wire I use a Neotechs best Occ 7-9s pure copper Teflon ,Awg 20 for the tweeter and Awg 16 for the bass,mids. Connectors a must copper ,gold
copper base metal for sure then Crap brass that’ doesnot sound nature and 3x less conductive. I like the new Mundorf Evo Copper gold Loudspeaker terminals
if you are going to do a Xover see it through completely also a fantastic cap true bargain are the Jantzen Alumen caps up to 10 uf ,if you have bigger caps mix in 10%- 20 % if possible if using like on big caps like 47 uf and good solder
I like the Cardas sounds good and flows good.