I don't think you're comparing apples with apples here...for the price and age difference, the Ayre had better be significantly better than the Magnavox.
You need to compare the Ayre to others in its price class to get a real idea if it's right for you.
The Ayre player is very lively, open and detailed to my ears, but still has a bit of warmth to it which is why it's so pleasing to listen to. So it might meet your needs, but so might a Simaudio player as they have a slightly warmer, slightly less detailed, yet quite similar sound signature as compared to the Ayre. When considering a $3K CD player, make sure to audition as much as you can - it's both informative and fun! One thing's for sure - you'll be amazed at how good CD's can sound.
You need to compare the Ayre to others in its price class to get a real idea if it's right for you.
The Ayre player is very lively, open and detailed to my ears, but still has a bit of warmth to it which is why it's so pleasing to listen to. So it might meet your needs, but so might a Simaudio player as they have a slightly warmer, slightly less detailed, yet quite similar sound signature as compared to the Ayre. When considering a $3K CD player, make sure to audition as much as you can - it's both informative and fun! One thing's for sure - you'll be amazed at how good CD's can sound.