"Light Loading" Amps - Music Refence and others...

On another thread, a discussion started regarding light loading amplifiers. Since it was a discussion on Vandersteen speakers, I thought it merited an new thread, especially since there is some difference of opinion.

The principle of light loading was prposed by Roger Modjeski of Music Reference.

He said (with reference to his RM10, but applicable to all his amps):

"The amplifier is flat within 0.1dB and has low distortion of 0.3% when played below clipping on average level material. At the recommended bias current of 30mA/pair, the idling dissipation is nine watts or 75% of the tubes' rating. I estimate tube life to be 5,000 to 10,000 hours. Although higher idling currents will reduce distortion, it can also be reduced by light loading. Basically, light loading reduces the output current demand on the output tubes, allowing them to be more linear. It also reduces noise, raises damping factor, reduces distortion by 78% and allows for 80% more peak current when needed. The only loss is about 20% of the power rating or 1dB." Light loading means connecting the speaker on the tap that's one half its nominal impedance rating (i.e. the 4-ohm tap for 8-ohm speakers). For 4-ohm speakers, the he recommends running two RM-10s bridged to 70-watt monoblocks.

In the aforementioned thread, Ralph Karsten of Atma-sphere said:

"If you use the 4 ohm tap on an amplifier with a speaker of higher impedance, the output transformer will be inadequately loaded, and so it will express less of its winding ratio and more of its inter-winding capacitance. This can result in the amplifier no longer having flat frequency response. In addition, the transformer can 'ring' if inadequately loaded, which is another way of saying that it will distort.

The Merlin is an 8 ohm load, with a dip to 6 ohms or so. Its a benign load and an amplifier with an output transformer, if the transformer is designed properly, will likely work best on the 8 ohm tap. This will minimize the artifact of the transformer."

Two views. And different views from listeners, somew thinking light loading works magic, other saying differently.

What do you think of the priciple. The two technical arguments? Your experiences with light loading?
I would describe the RM 10 - to steal a phrase... "starless & bible black". Dead quiet background, resolved, tone rich & fleeting fast. It commands your attention & just draws you in. The best audio purchase I've made to date. When I received my new RM 10 from Roger the 4 ohm taps were open where he had personally burned in my unit & listened to my unit for a week & I followed suit. Definitely the way to go.
Pehare, is the 40h tao indeed light loading for your speakers?
Pabul57. Yes, the Tannoy Westminster is nominally an 8 ohm load, and never drops below 6.5 ohms.
Although I do not employ the RM-10 with the Tannoy, it is one amazing little amplifier regardless of tap selection.

Pehare. Congrats on your new toy.
The Merlins VSMs are similar - 8ohm, 6.5 ohm minimum:) I
agree with you abut the RM10, it is one hell of good amp,
good enough that I sold the RM9 Special Edition ($10,000 -
162 watts!) While the RM 9 SE can drive many (any?)
speakers the RM10 might not be up to, but with the Merlins,
the little amp does the job without apologies. Combined with
an Lightspeed Attenuator, RM10 MKII, and 89db speakers with
smooth benign impedance curves, you have one heck of great
pre/amp combo capable of SOTA sound for $2,500 MSRP.
yes Paul, lite loaded for sure....they are a wonderful combo w/the RM10. I've tried & owned some other tube amps that sounded wretched in comparison w/these speakers. They don't suffer fools lightly.

Coincident Speaker Tech Partial Eclipse II
Frequency Response: 30hz - 30khz
Impedance:8 ohms ( min. 7.9 - max. 10 ohms )
Sensitivity: 92 db - 1w @ 1m
w/extender feet & oversize spikes