PS Audio BHK versus Herron VTSP-3A(ro2)

I'm currently using a Herron VTSP-3A(r02) pre amp.  I purchased a used mint condition BHK on agon; it arrived today.

My first impressions: With the BHK, streaming SQ is noticeably better than with the Herron. I'm using a DirectStream Sr. DAC. Playing vinyl with the BHK, the Herron sounds noticeably better. I'm using a Herron VTPH-2A phono pre.

All things being equal, when playing vinyl with the Herron/Herron combination, the sound is much stronger and fuller than when streaming the same CD quality song using the Herron/DSD combination.  With the BHK, its the exact opposite, that is, the BHK/DSD streaming sound is stronger than the BHK/Herron vinyl sound.  In both cases, I can increase the volume to achieve about the same sound. 

Playing vinyl, I prefer the Herron/Herron vinyl SQ.  For streaming, I prefer the BHK/DSD SQ.  I am a bit disappointed in the BHK/Herron vinyl sound. Even when I turn up the volume, it lacks the full bodied Herron/Herron sound.  Before I get too excited, I'm going to try different loading plugs to see if that helps. Any other ideas are welcomed.

558fadf1 1383 4405 8e35 4afd3670ff4coldschool1948
The volume difference you notice between the two pre's may be due to the differences in how they each handle gain.  I think the Herron is fixed at 14dB and the BHK uses a switched gain adjustment linked to its stepped volume controller.
If the Herron is SE all the way through and the Herron preamp provides 14 db gain then that explains the difference in level as the BHK in SE only provides 3 db gain so turn it up.  Are you connecting the DS Sr. to the BHK balanced and the Herron phono SE?
With the Herron, I'm using SE all the way.  With the BHK, its SE from the phono pre and balanced from the DSD.  I've noticed the Herron streaming sound is warmer and the BHK sound is more nuanced and detailed. 

Whenever I change a component, I play "East River Drive" by Stanley Clarke, "Crystal Morning" by Dave Grusin, "Since I Fell for You" by Brad Mehldau, "Imagine" by Randy Crawford, and "Insanity" by Gregory Porter / Lalah Hathaway.  Each has loud passages that the Herron tamed at my normal listening level, the BHK not so much.

I'm using a Matrix X SPDIF II between my Innous Zenith MK II and the DSD. WW Platinum Starlight 7 USB to the Matrix and a low budget HDMI cable to the DSD. I have Tannoy DC8Ti speakers.

I'm using a NAD M22v2 power amp.  NAD and class D don't get a lot of love on agon, but it sounds fine to my ears with the Herron. I want a warmer sound, so my next upgrade will be a tube power amp or mono blocks.

Before the BHK, I auditioned an LTA ZTOL40 and it sounded wonderful.- but it doesn't have balanced connections. I'm planning to move my gear from between my speakers to a side wall and will need a long interconnect to a power amp or long interconnects to a pair of monoblocks.  I'm thinking balanced is the best way to go.
Vol matching when comparing gear is important. Like you said, you can get the same sonics when turning one up more. So use a spl meter to match and then see what you like best. 
All too many A/B listening tests are skewed by mismatched volume levels.  As just said, unless the spls are pretty closely matched, comparative listening like this won't tell you too much.
I do have an spl, but I am not looking for scientific proof.  In this case, my ears tell me there's a big difference in the sound with the BHK.  There's also a difference with the Herron, but it's not as much and it is in reverse.  My concern is the BHK vinyl sound is a bit hollow when compared to the Herron at all volume levels.

Since I'm using XLR cables with the DSD and RCA cables with the Herron, I expected there to be a difference.  I believe with XLR it is +6db.  I don't expect them to match when I switch inputs.  I do want a fuller more robust BHK vinyl sound. 

I'm not having buyer's remorse.  Overall, I like the BHK for many reasons.  I'm 72.  As I get older, I stream more than I play vinyl.  But, when do, I want that Herron sound.  I've got some tinkering to do with Herron loading plugs to see if that improves things.
I am using both Herron pieces with a 15 foot run of RCA interconnects to my LTA UL No Problem!
@dodgealum Thanks for the feedback on the RCA length.