Proac vs. Meadowlark

I have had both ProAc Response 1 SC and Meadowlark Kestrel and Verio in my system with a CJ MV 60. They all work well with tubes. Each has its own strengths depending on what you want and expect. ProAc is more detailed or maybe brighter than Meadowlark. Meadowlark has a different sounding bass, maybe more bass. Midrange on both are close, with Meadowlark being a bit warmer. ProAcs are very stand dependent and Meadowlark need at least 6 feet between them to really image well.

What is your budget? There are options based upon price, music preference and the rest of your system.

Go with the Shearwater. I am not convinced about the new Meadowlarks yet. They are a different sound and I need to listen to them more. They still out perform many more expensive speakers. But my old ears do not want to change too much.

Although you narrowed the field down to these two brands, try and listen to Silverline.

RG is on target with his assessment. I gave my ProAcs (1SC) up due to fatigue. They are great but they also became bright sounding. I also found the 1 SC better than the 1.5 and 2.5 both were bass heavy to me and did not have that ProAc magic. (And the controversy begins.) Do not get me wrong because the 1 SC are one of my favorites.

I switched over to Penaudio from Finland. More expensive but worth it. Imaging ++++. Detail and accurate and musical!!! These are one of the best new speakers to hit the market. Silverline has several models to listen to. But since we are making alternative suggestions, you can also listen to Legend.

Isn't this what it's all about? Opinions and Options. KT 88 call me if you want to go over other options.

Hey!

ProAc and Meadowlark are two of my favorite brands. Comparing the two is always interesting. It is a great case of how different is not necessarily better. Just different and good in their own ways.

Anyway, it's Sunday night so let's have some fun and muddy the water a little before Monday morning. Please excuse me, but I am horrible with names. KT 88, look for an older pair of ProAc Signature 50s (retailed around 1700 new). Not Tablets. It may also be Reference 50s. They laid the foundation for the 1 SCs. They did a lot of things better, were warmer and had more body. Surprising speaker.

Penaudio solved the problem of subwoofer and stands. While they have a powered subwoofer line, they are introducing an interesting new line of passive woofers. Maybe a pair of those with the ProAcs? Mine (woofers)are on the way.

KT 88 if you need some help finding some Shearwaters send me an e-mail.

Have a good week everyone!

OK, the field is opened. While KT 88 had his mind set for either ProAc or Meadowlark, new input has surfaced. OK, if we are opening this up, let's keep it focused. KT 88 please present your parameters. Existing system. Objectives. Budget. Etc. Let's see what comes to light.

Well, you are either a glutton for punishment or you are giving yourself more than a fair chance to pick a speaker that you want to keep for a while. ProAc is very stand dependent, so a floor stander is a more desired option. Well, I like monitors and I like good two way speakers. So here's two more. Silverline SR15 new or SR 17 new at a pinch or used within the budget. You do not have to get crazy with the stands as long as they are stable and can be filled. You want them 24". Can you find used Legends at this price range? I cannot comment on Mdp's suggestions as I have not listened to Soliloguy long enough at any one time. But since you are open, give them a listen and let us know what you think.