Live or Recorded; A Faustian response


I just responded to a Faustian question about
whether I had a choice between music or my stereo system. How about the choice between live concerts or recorded
music??? If I had more time in my hectic life:
live concerts( I just heard a wonderful Brahms' Sextet by a local sting ensemble) but.....
shubertmaniac

Showing 2 responses by gregm

I third the motions above for the reasons advanced. Adding to Albert's quest for tickets, may I also add Furtwangler, Backhaus, Richter, Ferrier, Walter, J Campbell, Hooker, Waters, and many others.
Other than the music per se, the live performance offers ambience, and human interaction and contact. If we call such "surrounding" aspects of the live experience, "atmosphere" (for wont of a better word), then atmosphere, inseparable from the music, can beget magic. At home, we would have a more solitary "atmosphere".
This same "atmosphere" at home is of solitary ilk; when I listen to (say) Furt, I am in a phantasy world of nostalgia. So, authentic experience? Mr Heidegger would probably disagree -- but Mr Kant may not! But the question of whether I can experience Furtwangler live is clearly metaphysical, isn't it? Cheers.