2. digital
  3. 159545-123196

Keep investing in peripherals to make expensive an DAC work in my system, or get a new DAC

I recently purchased a DCS Bartok for headphone use and I’ve had some real struggles getting it not to kill my ears with slam, transients and edgy highs. I have a great Shunyata-based power/cable system, a Innuos Zenith as network server connected with Shunyata Sigma Ethernet, and a number of headphone cables for my Meze Empyrean. I just didn’t like the Bartok’s headphone amp, so I’m using an Audeze The King MkII, which sounds a lot better. I also found that the USB input, while generally inferior, is easier on my ears. 

I liked what I heard at the retailer reasonably well, but did not have a chance to audition on my own system. And I can’t return it.

Anyway, for a system where the transducers are right by my ears I’ve had to make a lot of tweaks and it looks like I now have two options:

1. Put my hopes into upgrading my ethernet connection with an EtherRegen and even more spendy ethernet cables to get a smoother sound AND buy another expensive headphone cable with a warmer balance. AND maybe even try a different power cable.

2. Sell the almost new Bartok at a loss and get a smoother USB-centered DAC like a used EMM Labs DA2 and an Innuos Phoenix for using USB. This will ultimately cost me quite a bit over what I’ve already spend (yikes) and take me away from network playback, though my Innuos is a streamer anyway. 

At what point do you conclude that it isn’t the digital sources, cables etc. and just get a different DAC, after having sunk so much money already?
ianb52
8 responses Add your response
yyzsantabarbara
4,461 posts
 
I have the Meze Empy but not a lot of headphone experience. I get fatigue real quick with a bad setup so I was reluctant to go to headphones but I took a chance. I now have the Benchmark HPA4 and the Bryston BHA-1 headphone amps. I upgraded my Meze cable to the WyWire Platinum XLR. In fact I sent it in yesterday to WyWire to upgrade it from 5 foot to 9 foot length.

The WyWire with the Bryston was too fatiguing with that amp (the bass was not tight). Switching to the warmer stock Meze cable for the Bryston amp made the fatigue go down by a tremendous amount. I currently only play the Bryston with the stock cable and a warm sounding 20 year old Sony SCD-1 SACD player. It is a very enjoyable sound.

The WyWire and the Benchmark HPA4 are an incredible combo. I would not trade it for anything. The extra details in the WyWire cable is presented in a non-fatiguing way on with the HPA4. I listen to the Meze about 4+ hours a day (8 hours today) since I do not have 2 channel amps this month. I flip the Meze cable between stock and WyWIre when I switch amps.

So my suggestion is to try the warmer stock Meze cable with your Bartok first. It has less detail but maybe can tame whatever harshness you are encountering. I find my Bryston BHA-1 inferior to my Benchmark HPA4, especially in the control of bass. I also think the Meze is an incredible headphone.

BTW - you will get better answers than mine here,
https://www.head-fi.org/threads/dcs-bartok.901647/

ianb52 OP
40 posts
 
Thanks for your suggestion. Going back to the stock Meze cable *almost* totally removes the fatigue, but as you said it is a bit warm and less detailed. 
I actually had a BHA-1 for a while, but it was way too edgy for me. I've heard good things about the HPA4. 
yyzsantabarbara
4,461 posts
 
Why not give the HPA4 a free home trial. You put the Bartok  XLR outputs into input #1 of the HPA4 which is supposed to be optimized for DACs. 

Last night I went to bed listening to the BHA-1 + Meze and Springsteen's River album. That edginess you and I hear bothered the heck out of me. What did you replace your BHA-1 with? The BHA-1 does s few things I like, such as analog inputs and XLR outputs to external speakers. I would love to find something that has that feature set. I only paid $900 for my 10/10 used unit so I am keeping it around but I do get annoyed by it.
yyzsantabarbara
4,461 posts
 
Yesterday I was discussing the LA4 with someone who uses is the Davinci DAC from DCS. He uses the LA4 (same as the HPA4 minus headphone amp) and thinks it is great. Maybe your sound issue is the headphone amp of the Bartok.

https://forum.audiogon.com/discussions/benchmark-la4-preamp
(near the end of this thread)
ianb52 OP
40 posts
 
It’s not a bad suggestion, but I’m thinking the issue isn’t the headphone amp. I have a few options already, The King MkII, an LTA MZ3 tube amp, and the pretty decent solid state amp in my Mytek Manhattan II. I haven’t tried hooking up the Mytek yet (the only one that can do balanced) but The King is extremely good, and the MZ3 is more smooth and rounded and yet still struggles with some of these intense transients from the Bartok. 

My suspicion is that it’s either just the DCS sound, a power cable incompatibility, an unrefined digital input, or all three. The problem is, a lot of money gets spend before I know for sure that it’s just the DAC.


After the BHA-1 I briefly used a Lehmann Black Cube Linear which was nice, similar to the Bryston but not harsh, and fewer features, but for a long time I just used the Mytek headphone amp which is surprisingly good. I even kept using it with my Direcstream DAC until I finally switched over to the tube ones, although it is actually almost as good.
djones51
4,947 posts
 
Have you tried using the DSP filters? 
yyzsantabarbara
4,461 posts
 
Thanks for the feedback on the "after BHA-1 amps". I will take a look at the first 2 you mentioned. I am also going to look at this amp,

Broadway by Eleven Audio XIAUDIO Fully Balanced Headphone Amplifier

https://abyss-headphones.com/collec...io-fully-balanced-battery-headphone-amplifier

I am definitely going to sell my BHA-1. Nice little push from your post. 

*****

If you have the stock Bartok power cable still around try that to rule out the after market power cable incompatibility. 

Are you aware of the following Bartok review from Austinpop on Computer Audiophile?
https://audiophilestyle.com/ca/reviews/dcs-bartok-review-r849/

You may want to consider posting a question on that thread or direct PM to the reviewer. 
nekoaudio's avatar
nekoaudio
489 posts
 
I think you would be best-off looking for a different DAC.
Log in to respond
More to discover
80x80
Esoteric DV-60
80x80
RME ADI-2 DAC
80x80
Audio Research DAC1-20