Jazz for aficionados


Jazz for aficionados

I'm going to review records in my collection, and you'll be able to decide if they're worthy of your collection. These records are what I consider "must haves" for any jazz aficionado, and would be found in their collections. I wont review any record that's not on CD, nor will I review any record if the CD is markedly inferior. Fortunately, I only found 1 case where the CD was markedly inferior to the record.

Our first album is "Moanin" by Art Blakey and The Jazz Messengers. We have Lee Morgan , trumpet; Benney Golson, tenor sax; Bobby Timmons, piano; Jymie merrit, bass; Art Blakey, drums.

The title tune "Moanin" is by Bobby Timmons, it conveys the emotion of the title like no other tune I've ever heard, even better than any words could ever convey. This music pictures a person whose down to his last nickel, and all he can do is "moan".

"Along Came Betty" is a tune by Benny Golson, it reminds me of a Betty I once knew. She was gorgeous with a jazzy personality, and she moved smooth and easy, just like this tune. Somebody find me a time machine! Maybe you knew a Betty.

While the rest of the music is just fine, those are my favorite tunes. Why don't you share your, "must have" jazz albums with us.

Enjoy the music.
orpheus10

Showing 50 responses by rok2id

***** the USA and USMC combined can't put 100,000 infantry in the Field .*****

As warfare and tech advances, fewer and fewer infantry are required.

Fewer and fewer everything to be exact.

We have about 8000 M1 tanks.  Quite a few of those in storage.  We made 50,000 Sherman Tanks in WWll.  The reason, the M1 is indestructible, the armor has never been penetrated, and the main gun does not miss unless the crew makes a  mistake.

One M1 was disabled in Iraq when the track was hit.  A British tank, which has similar armor to ours, took 48 hits in Iraq after it track was disabled.  The crew was not harmed.

The F15 has never suffered a combat loss.

Don't need a lot of stuff these days.   Just a lot of brains.

Cheers
Today's Listen:

Herbie Hancock  --  GERSHWIN'S WORLD
with a cast of everyone.   If you're looking for music to improvise over, Gershwin's music is a great place to start.

Cast includes the ones listed here plus, James Carter, Chick Corea, Kenny Garrett, Orpheus chamber Orchestra and others.

Stevie Wonder
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SRUFC4NN6js  
Kathleen Battle
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nq-ak_-6gX8   
Joni Mitchell
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r83bUyTFH0U  
Wayne Shorter
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_C-jUAQJzWo  

Don't have it?   And you call yourself an Aficionado.

Nice Booklet and notes.   A lot of talk about Ravel.

Cheers

I have always heard that the U.S. Air Force, and esp the Air Force Academy are 'born again' organizations.  Which I think is a good thing.   Colorado Springs being the perfect place for that.

Of course Nuclear war is unthinkable.   That's why Nuclear Weapons are effective.   They keep the peace.   The motto of the Strategic Air Command was, 'Peace is Our Profession'.   Always brought a smile to my face, but, they were correct.

All wars start after a series of calculations by opposing forces / countries.   In the Nuclear age, no matter what  info you put in the war game computer, the end result is the same.   Everything is destroyed and Everybody dies.

Take away the Nukes, and the computer might say, WE WIN!!
And, there we go.

Also, we can never know how many wars Nuclear weapons have prevented.

Very informative clip.

Cheers
Today's Listen:

Coleman Hawkins  --  DESAFINADO
Hawkins with guys I never heard of.  During the Bossa Nova craze.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Spp2Pe9Whik   

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IOlPsz_jrpQ  

it's not what, but how you play.  Jelly Roll was right.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dyhl-K5_Rvk  

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5FX_60garHY  

Cheers
Carolyn Lee Jones:

Very nice.  Was not familiar with her, but Jazz can always use more Texas.

Cheers
Bach & Jazz:

The Good Lord continues to test me.

The Blues on Bach thing is nice music.  So is the Swingle Singers.  I even have a CD of both groups together.  It's nice music because it's played by consummate professionals.   I'm sure MJQ can play Bach.   I know they can play Jazz.  They just can't play both at the same time, within the same tune.  And if MJQ couldn't pull it off, no one can.  They even dress the part.

I must have misplaced my copy of Schubert (the real Schubert) At The Blue Note.  Perhaps, Vivaldi at Newport.   Hog Calling Blues for String Quartet?

This is the closest anyone has ever come, and wiki says it's 'Orchestral Jazz'.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ynEOo28lsbc

wiki --- " Rhapsody in Blue is a 1924 musical composition by the American composer George Gershwin for solo piano and jazz band, which combines elements of classical music with jazz-influenced effects. "

Nice try.  No Cigar.

Cheers
The OP is correct, as he sometimes is, on this.   ANYTHING western is a great curiosity there, and if it's done by black folks, it becomes THE THING.  When ever  I see / hear Jazz played in Asia, I think, another great performance wasted on foreign ears.

To them, its a sign they are wealthy and have become a rich / important nation in the world.   They can import Miles.   How cool is that.   It's a prestige thing.

Reminds  me of a DVD I once ordered titled 'Ray Charles In Brazil'.  Now that just had to a killer DVD.   We know what Ray brings, then we think of Rio, Babes, Carnival etc......  How can it miss?
    
Well, it remains the worst DVD I have ever purchased.   Performed on a nondescript high school like stage in front of the then ruling Junta, and their 'ladies'.  It was a prestige thing.   So as Ray and the Raelettes did their best, the audience just sat there like stone soldiers.

Big Time foreign entertainment, esp American, is seen as proof that a country has 'arrived' in many parts of the world.

Cheers
Today’s Listen:

Ella Fitzgerald / Duke Ellington -- ELLA FITZGERALD SINGS THE DUKE ELLINGTON SONGBOOK
Ella sings with small groups and full orchestra.

2CD set. Excellent booklet with pictures. I could have posted them all, it’s that good. 37 total tracks. All the Jazz greats play on this session. Too many to list.

with orchestra, check the Trumpet playing.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-mB45AIHJ04&list=OLAK5uy_kfU4X2p8rBHukodapKaobAgzPJRe4410c

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xMz01jD1634&list=OLAK5uy_kfU4X2p8rBHukodapKaobAgzPJRe4410c&index=4

with small groups

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b-XCw8dlrxQ&list=OLAK5uy_kfU4X2p8rBHukodapKaobAgzPJRe4410c&index=15

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=83L8ol-SYnQ&list=OLAK5uy_kfU4X2p8rBHukodapKaobAgzPJRe4410c&index=20

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7xikVWnJVgc&list=OLAK5uy_kfU4X2p8rBHukodapKaobAgzPJRe4410c&index=24


Ain’t got it, git it.

Cheers



***** Moreover, those dancers may have given a more inspired performance because they were relaxed.*****

My point exactly.   You make my argument for me.   I just said the audience can and do effect the performers.

***** If in fact those dancers were to feel “life changing” pressure when performing at home how does that compare to what Miles might feel playing for a college crowd?*****

If Stalin is your critic, you are perfect or in the gulag.   That may affect your performance.

Miles, I don't know the man, MAY have thought these guys wouldn't know great Jazz if it fell on them.   That may affect his performance.   He may have gotten sloppy, he may have been 'relaxed' and played inspired Jazz.   Does not matter.   My point is who you play for can affect how and what you play.

I am sure personality plays a part.   Miles may have not given a F*** who was present, he just played what he felt like playing.

But I tend to think that if he showed up a venue to play, and in the first row of the audience sat, Coltrane, Ellington, Monk, Armstrong, Bird and Lee Morgan.   I think if would affect him.   I could be wrong.

***** May I ask how many performers you have spoken to about this?  *****

Miles, Trane and I lost contact years ago.   One got lost, one turned into Sinbad.  

Cheers


I didn't say he would. That is the question.   But, I think artists do consider the audience when they play.   The appreciation level of the audience.

Say a Jazz-wise audience in a NYC Jazz club, compared to a college crowd or even something like the Kennedy Center Honors program.

People that come out to hear not only Jazz, but a particular Jazz player,  vs  people who may be in the audience for any number of reasons.

A few years ago the Bolshoi Ballet came to our town.   The place was packed.   Now, I don't think there are that many ballet lovers in central Texas.   But it was a big deal, and everyone wanted to be there.   

The performance was magnificent!!!!   How do I know?  Because no one fell down.  I bet the dancers knew that would be how they would be judged.  In small town Texas.   The most pressure-free performance they will ever give.

The audience does have an effect on the performers.

Cheers
The question, to me,  seems to be, do touring American Jazz artists feel they have to 'put on a show' in front of foreign audiences.

In other words, Would Miles, Trane, or any  other top tier Jazz player,  play any Jazz music,  in  Korea or Japan, the same as they would in NYC?

It's a yes or no answer.

Cheers
 the Swingle Singers are not jazz, not in the strict sense.  Is "jazzy" a better term?  So far as my limited musical knowledge takes me, they are singing Bach's score.

Based on this, there is no problem,  or even disagreement.  MJQ tried to merge the two genres.  Sort of like so-called 'fusion' is supposed to be the merger of Jazz and rock.
   Non-Jazz groups singing Bach is no problem.   Even if they try to 'Jazz' it up.  Jazz groups playing Bach is OK, It still remains Bach.  Which ain't bad.   Third Stream was a dead-end.   That is my only point.  They never made it work.  If they did, share with the rest of us.

Cheers
I know the Lord is testing me.

My point was that the dancers should have been very relaxed compared to, say, performing before the Soviet elites back in the day.  Where a lapse in the artistic area could have been life changing.   For something we would not have noticed.

Stop being so disingenuous.   My point is correct and stands.

Cheers

I know they never fall down.   Maybe they fall off their toes.  :):)
I’’m pretty sure that most of them , in a month or two , could have played jazz as well as they did classical .

They may have been able to play some improvised music following the rules of music theory.  Jazz?  That's a different matter altogether.  Jazz is hard.  Esp Jazz on a level that people will pay to hear.  Takes more than 'rigorous' training.

Cheers


***** rok , are you related to MacArthur ?*****

No, but he was the Greatest General this country has produced.

Recommended for the Medal of Honor twice.
Was a general in the First World War
Was Army Chief of Staff before world war 2
retired and ran the military of the Philippines.
Recalled after Pearl Harbor
Wrote the Japanese Constitution which is still in effect.
Defeated the North Koreans in the Korean war with a master stroke at Inchon

His strategy in the southwest Pacific was to, ’hit them where they ain’t’
If he had commanded all ground forces, including the USMC, it would have been a different war. A lot more guys would have made it back home.

Cheers

One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich is a novel by Nobel Prize-winning Russian writer Alexander Solzhenitsyn. It depicts a typical day in the life of a inmate, or Zek, in the Soviet Gulag during the time of Stalin.

If The Frogman had lived in Russia during those times, and with his attitude, we would be reading "One Day in the Life of The Frogman".

Cheers

Btw, Solzhenitsyn served many years in the gulag himself. Crime? He criticized someone / something, while he was a Captain, in command of a Red Army tank unit fighting in Poland towards the end of the war.

You must not only obey big brother, you must also love big brother.
Today's Listen:

Stanley Turrentine  --  HUSTLIN'
with wife Shirley Scott on Organ.   Burrell on guitar.

I was just looking thru my computer printout of all my Jazz LPs.  I no longer have a turntable setup. 
I was surprised to see that the artist most represented was not Miles nor Trane,  but Stanley Turrentine.  Let's see what all the fuss was about.   Interesting to see how your tastes change over time.

Great album cover.   Blue Note was a master at that.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F9O4a-2D3Vk

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Mu1aoHoo9s

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PUHEuBge5z8

Cheers
There is a famous, or maybe infamous, true story of Stalin up late at night reviewing a list from the NKVD.  A list of names of people to be arrested and or shot.  Went to Stalin for his signature.  Thousands of names.  Stalin read them all, struck a few off, and then at the end of the list he signs it, and then adds, "six thousand more, no matter who."

With all due respect, 'intellect' and respect for 'intellectuals' does not enter into it.

Einstein's, Niels Bohr's, and Edward Teller's intellect told them to get the f*** out of dodge.

Cheers
@Jazz queen

The posting of people like  Ornette Coleman and Sun Ra is supposed to signal that the thread is in it's death throes.   Is the end near?

Cheers
So, what exactly is the problem?


There is no problem.   Just a statement of fact.

  I'm sure MJQ can play Bach.  I know they can play Jazz. They just can't play both at the same time, within the same tune. And if MJQ couldn't pull it off, no one can. They even dress the part.

Cheers
schubert,

There are a few You-tube clips that are on my regular goto play list.  That one by Ahmad you posted is one of them.

So is this one:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gfNIVdnz1FQ

Cheers

Today’s Listen:

Randy Weston -- PORTRAITS OF DUKE ELLINGTON
part of a trilogy called ’Protraits’. Ellington, Monk, Self.

Best when heard loud thru Polks. Not sure what all that is at the start of ’Caravan’. Getting the camels up in the morning?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GiLrbOgweSo

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x8nlgeJh5Gc

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b-Ku9LJXrOY

Good notes and booklet. Talks about the Duke being very religious, and how he wrote music not only for the different instruments, but for the particular players that played those instruments.

Cheers
***** we share the same ideals; the ideals of FDR, JFK, and MLK, and I will never quit fighting for those ideals.*****

Ideals are fine, but are pretty useless unless acted upon.

I prefer the ACTIONS of people like Harry Truman, Dwight Eisenhower, and Lyndon Johnson.

Cheers
***** Personally, and not meaning to get personal 😊, I think a far more interesting question is why, in the face of so much musicological supporting evidence, not to mention the practically universal opinion of Jazz players, you are so bothered by the notion.*****

The musicological "evidence" is agenda driven and therefore bogus.   The players are great players, but their education and knowledge ends there.

I am bothered because it's not true, and those people don't deserve 'credit' for anything based on the work and struggle of people in this country, just because of skin color.

Cheers
Nice Weston clips.   Lest any aficionado becomes confused, Mr Weston was born in Brooklyn New York.   The references to Africa and the costumes notwithstanding.

I will never understand the silly compulsion some  Jazz players have to try and connect Jazz with Africa.   There is no connection.

For the life of me, I can't understand why they would even want there to be.

Cheers
More African music:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uUcEGOLfUTE
could have been called the  Kenyan blues

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BJ_4cRG8B1g
wow!!   I thought I was in the Congo!!!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6sOygJsLDc4
if you don't hear the African in this, you're deaf.

Cheers
***** What kind of prize do I win?*****

You get all my Kenny G 8-track tapes, and a slightly used color 8"x12" picture of Spike Jones, suitable for framing.

This is your lucky day.

Cheers

Btw, your Jazz sensibilities are as sharp as ever.
Cultural anthropology is more to the point than Musicology.

Where are the African Languages?
Where are the African Religions? Even Islam didn’t survive.
Where are all the things that made them African?
None survived the trip and assimilation.

Except Jazz / music, or so you and the music ’establishment’ would have us believe. I suspect you don’t have a real grasp of the nuts and bolts of slavery. Keeping groups / families together, was not a consideration. Impossible to maintain anything under those conditions.

Every style of European music that was brought to this country, is still being played here and in EUROPE today. Easy to trace.

What music is being played in Africa today? The only music, except primitive noise making, I have ever heard was brought to Africa from the West. Where is the music that gave rise to Jazz?

Remember, in a lot of places in Africa, even today, music is frowned upon.

Cheers

Btw, when someone from one culture, defines and explains another group's culture, watch out!!




Jazz if anything, means freedom.   It is the music of freedom of expression and ideals.   So why does it attract so many socialists?

I need answers people.

Cheers
Climate Change:

Can you think of a species more deserving of going extinct than us?

Cheers

***** I also believe that the "Jazz Messengers" produced the best groups and best music in the history of modern jazz.*****

an outrageous provocation.

Cheers

Army nurses that hold the rank of LTC / COL, are surely some of the toughest folks in the military.

Once I was in the 97th General Hospital in Frankfurt, and due to the draw down in Nam, I had 5 (five) nurses, all full colonels, giving me their undivided attention. No Nonsense indeed.

Cheers
I guess someone forgot to tell the rulers in Pyongyang, Beijing, Phnom Penh, Moscow, Hanoi and even Zagreb.

There is always the 10% that never get the memo.

Cheers
***** Why don't you send that "social security check" back to the government. Do you use "Medicare"?*****

Why should I send it back?  I have been employed since the 6th grade.   I paid my share.

Cheers
The Government says,  if:
1.   you do not have children out of wedlock
2.   you do not have any children before age 20
3.   you finish high school
4.   you are not addicted to drugs

YOU WILL NOT BE POOR !!

Actually not a very high bar at all.

Cheers
***** Have you ever heard of a "Social Democracy"?*****

Is that anything like a "workers paradise"?

Cheers

***** In regard to the messengers; put up or shut up.*****

Let me put up the following:

Louis Armstrong  &   Hot 5/7
Duke Ellington and his orchestra
Count Basie and his orchestra
Cab Calloway and his orchestra

Take your pick

Cheers
Sadly, poverty is a vital part of capitalism.  It's the great motivator.

Imagine a country where the government promised and actually made sure everyone was in the middle class.

Then imagine one where everyone was in the middle class and no one richer than the middle class.   By government decree.

Equal men aren't free and free men aren't equal.   Nature's law.

Cheers