Is it caused by the transport or the dac?


I am auditioning a new transport. I am currently using a Theta Data Basic II with the Musical Fidelity Tri-Vista 21 DAC. I'm looking for a transport because the Data Basic II is rather old, I had to replace the drawer unit last summer, and basically I'm concerned that's its time is near.

Auditioning the new transport is puzzling. There's what seems to be 'funny' things going on, and I don't know if it's in the transport's reading of the CD, or the DAC's receiving and translating what's being sent to it.

At times the bass is almost non-existent with the new transport and at other times fine, whereas the Theta Data Basic II is consistantly powerful in the bass region. The bass seems to disappear more when the music gets complicated.

The same for the midrange. If the music is simple, i.e. vocalist, one or two non-distorted guitars, bass and simple drums. the sound is much better than through the Theta. Better textures, dynamics, etc. However, add distorted guitars, overdubbed guitars, powerful drums, basically anything more complex, and a general smearing occurs where the clarity of the individual instruments and vocals had been.

Sometimes there's even a very quick stop in the music throughout the song, like 'I can't figure out what the data is that I'm dealing with, so I won't output anything!'

This only occurs with the new unit, it doesn't happen at all with the Theta. Like I said though, on simple songs the music sounds quite a bit better in all areas.

Is the transport having the problem reading the data in the complicated passages? Is the transport sending more information to the M.F. Tri-Vista 21 DAC than the DAC can process? This is perplexing!

Thanks,
Chuck
krell_man

Showing 2 responses by krell_man

The new transport is a dealer demo that I'm auditioning, so it does have a number of hours on it. I'm also running it 24 hours a day myself. I don't want to name the transport because if it doesn't work in my system, that doesn't mean that it won't work in someone else's.

It's gotten really good reviews, and I don't want anyone not trying it because of this particular situation. I'm wondering if it's so good at retrieving the data, it's sending more data than the Tri-Vista 21 can handle.

I have the DAC set to upsampling to 192Hz and maybe it needs to be lower. I listened to the new Cary 303/300 and noticed that the higher the upsampling rate on certain recordings, the more raspy it sounded. I assume due to the dithering.
John and Jose,

Thanks for your thoughts! I’m going to go ahead and expose the transport, because I believe that I should. It is the $1,500.00 Stello CDT200 from April Music. Anthony at Aberdeen Components, http://www.aberdeencomponents.com, in Las Vegas recommended it and offered to give me a 60 day trial period to make sure that I liked it.

I ordered one from him, but he found out that there’s a three week wait for them, so he overnighted me his demo. I received it yesterday right after lunch and have had it playing ever since. I assumed that it was well broken in from the way Anthony said it sounded, pretty much the best new thing since sliced bread at or above its price point. I read his feedback and the reviews at http://www.aprilmusic.com, and believed that I could trust him.

Right out of the box it sounded pretty special and I was really excited. Last night I discovered that it was behaving in the manner I described on the more complex musical pieces. I posted the thread because I was trying to figure out what was going on. I heard what Anthony had talked about, and then I heard those other very unacceptable things.

I reacted much too quickly, because tonight it’s opened up and it’s every bit as special as Anthony said it was. The dynamics are so strong that I’ve had to turn the volume down to allow for the swells not waking up the neighborhood. I don’t think that the layering within the soundstage is quite as deep as it is with the Theta Data Basic II, but that’s the only place it doesn’t easily kick its rear. Everything is now distinct and crystal clear even in the most complex songs I have. The biggest bonus is the added textures and the more natural sounding voices and instruments.

That’s saying quite a bit, especially if you’ve read what I have in my system. Two weeks ago I was told by another dealer that at the system level I am at, I’d have to jump up to the $4,000.00 - $5,000.00 price point to get a significant transport upgrade since the Theta Data Basic II was $2,000.00. I guess he’s never heard the Stello!

Chuck