Is a tube amp for me?


I've been an 'audiophile' for over 20 years. I've experimented with tubed preamps unsucessfully (I should add that later I found out the problem was a ground loop hum with my cable company, which didn't affect solid state preamps). I've been a SS guy for the rest of my audio life. Reliability is of utmost importance to me, and tube horror stories have scared me off. Sound quality is also very important, but not at the cost of chronic repairs. I currently am driving a pair of Vienna Acoustic Beethovens (4 ohms, 91 db sens) with a Threshold T400 amp (300 wpc into 4 ohms). I also have a Classe CP-60 and CDP-1.
I've listened to a BAT VK-60 and a Cary V-12 at a local dealer. The dealer would not let me bring the amps home, they sounded very good in his showroom. My question to you, my A-gon friends, is, is it worth the risk to try a tube amp? Or is it all hype? Should I just stick with my old, reliable Class A SS? What do ya say? Thanks for any input.
I should add that I couldn't afford to 'try' a tube amp without selling/trading my current amp (Threshold T-400). So it's not just a matter of trying a tube amp and keeping my SS amp in case things don't work out.

Regards,
John
128x128jmcgrogan2

Showing 2 responses by viridian

Broken anything is a hassle, but I would like to point out that, typically, when tube gear fails you lose a tube, maybe a resistor or two, a cap, fairly minor repairs and you are up and running again. Solid state gear is more prone to fail catastrophically taking out large chunks of circuit, output transistors, speakers and the like. There are plenty of solid state horror stories too. That said, from your post it doesn't sound like tubes are for you. They do demand greater involvment from the user, and they do sound quite different from solid state. It sounds like you already know the answer and genuinely enjoy the system that you have assembled.
ANGELA, I OWN TWO TUBE TESTERS. A MILITARY TYPE TV-7 THAT IS QUITE COMPACT AND IMPERVIOUS TO ABUSE AND A HICKOCK 752 WHICH IS VERY SLICK AS YOU DO NOT HAVE TO CHANGE SETTINGS TO TEST BOTH SIDES OF A DUAL TRIODE. BY THE WAY, EVEN THOUGH I OWN BOXES FULL OF NOS TUBES I DON'T OWN ANY TUBE GEAR AT THIS TIME. WHO SAID AUDIOPHILES WEREN'T NEUROTIC.