how can a cheap cd drive equal a fine transport?


Once a "perfect" file is on a HD, I grasp why playback may be better than reading data from a drive in real-time. But when ripping a cd, the digital data stream is read by a cd drive, i.e, a flimsy, cheap transport. The best transports produce a data stream with less error, or jitter. Large amounts of error correction are audible, so presumably, the less error correction applied, the better. So at the point where the cd is read by a drive, before applying error correction, before it even reaches a HD (or the prior optimal solution, a Genesis Digital Lens), how can a cheap computer drive produce a data stream comparable to a good transport? How can programs which try it 64 times, or whatever, produce a better result? Aren't they just using error correction (or checksum algorthms to determine which attempt got the best result, out of many error-laden reads) compensate for high initial error rates? Are fine transports almost pointless, now?
128x128lloydc

Showing 1 response by bombaywalla

The best transports produce a data stream with less error, or jitter.
the above statement is the flaw in your thinking, Lloydc (the jitter part is right tho'). The fact is that even the $35 el-cheapo DVD unit from Walmart will read a disk with zero errors (just like the transport for a $10K CDP). As Al indicated in this thread & Kijanki in another similar thread, these drives are packed with some very effective error correction algorithms that will zero out any errors within a certain range - 2.5mm to 8.5mm as indicated by Kijanki. So, bit stream is going to be perfect with cheap or expensive drives.
Where the expensive drives win big-time is their ability to read the disk with zero errors and at the same time not corrupt the power supply voltage during the read, minimize jitter, prevent disk wobble, etc. All these fine attributes of expensive drives are valid when you are playing back a CD real-time - these attributes prevent "digititis" in the listener.
These attributes are less meaningful when your playback method is computer audio. You've already ack that you understand this bit so no need to repeat. In computer-based audio, you worry about other things: disk speed, ensuring that you bypass KMIXER in Windows, ensure you are doing WASAPI in Win7, USB-to-SPDIF/XLR conversion, etc, etc.