HDMI 1.3 Audio Signal - Good Enough, or no?


I own an Arcam AVR350. As many know, this AVR, among a few others, eschews the HDMI connection for audio (providing switching for video only), citing it as a path largely inferior to other alternatives for truly quality audio reporoduction. Even with the introduction of HDMI 1.3, Arcam stands by the decision they made with respect to HDMI 1.1 and appears to have no plans to accommodate the HDMI audio path in the near future.

My question is whether most folks think that audio quality considerations in a home theater environment are important enough such that the HDMI 1.3 audio route would be "good enough" for HDTV and HD/Blue-Ray DVD. Or, is it really only a factor if you are using the AVR with both an HD cable/satellite receiver AND a high-quality audio source like SACD or DVD-A?
4yanx

Showing 2 responses by audiotomb

I also recently bought an Arcam AVR 350

Mine will be used only as my HT setup - BLu Ray
I'm using a PS3 now, but will buy a Pioneer BDF05 (May release) which will output 7 discrete analog outputs with dac converters. THe new $2k Denon will do this also.

THe Arcam is a beautiful sounding unit, well above the mass marketed hdmi receivers. I'm using a Pioneer plasma and will send the BLu Ray video direct to the plasma and audio via analog outputs to the Arcam

you may be able to do your HD receiver with toslink

Arcam felt the hdmi inputs compromised the sound quality

I've heard there are major problems getting the hdmi 1.3 chips
http://www.avrevforum.com/showthread.php?t=1377
4yank -

I'm in a similar boat as I'm mostly doing the ht room to watch movies (dvd and blue ray) and will probably hook up satelitte (I'll switch from dish network which has less HD content).
I'm hoping the newest 7.1 / 5.1 analog out high end blu ray players have a stellar SD DVD upsample section.

my old main system 2 channel ht seemed good enough
but was ready and willing to play with multi
the Arcam had a pleasing analog element even if it doesn't have the latest hdmi elements

tom