harmonic distortion and frequency response


i spoke to the designer of the chimera cables, a small firm in texas, following a recommendation and a favorable comment from my friend who purchased a one meter pair of interconnect cables.

i discussed with hime the obvious effect of frequency response on perceived "tonal" balance and he mentioned that two components, including cables could measure the same with respect to frequency response, but if one had more odd order harmonic distortion, it might be experienced as unpleasant.

given the fact that most components are designed with very low levels of harmonic ditortion, i thought that frequency response, i.e., spectral balance is the main concern with respect to "tonal" balance.

could someone explain the relationship between perceived unpleasantness of sound, spectral balance and harmonic distortion ?

whne correcting problems in stereo system performance, it may be easier to correct for peaks and dips than to ferret out problems caused by harmonic distortion.
mrtennis

Showing 1 response by gregm

I think you are asking about a few things.
3rd order linear & non-linear distortion: this is very often encountered when a SS amp is pushed beyond its energy providing capabilities (the amp is "clipping"): the resulting sound will be compressed (you tell by the amplitude) and one sonic byproduct is a generation of 3rd order harmonics of the original signal -- which are not part of the signal fed into the amp. These in turn are fed into yr speaker which will reproduce them.
Humans find these sounds strident, unnatural. We are used to accepting 2nd order harmonics: hit a resonant item and you'll hear the basic sound (fundamental) and other sounds, higher in pitch -- these are 2nd order harmonics. Musical intruments naturally produce 2nd order harmonics; some of these are captured in recordings and are reproduced, allowing us to distinguish between different instruments, voices, etc.

Such distortion, at high amplitude, is rare in normal operating conditions.

(BTW, the sine waves used in testing, are "pure" waves in that they don't contain harmonics -- i.e. they are unnatural sounds, but useful for test purposes only.)

Another question I think you;re asking concerns the sound emanating from the speakers: frequency response and "tonal balance". I don;t know, but assume, you use these expressions interchangeably; however, the ultimate sonic result in a room is of course the product of a system as a whole. In this case, there are many factors that determine the "quality" of the sound; one of these is frequency response -- but, within limits (~+/- 5db spl) it;s not the most important one; phase, power response, extension... are just a few.
Cheers