Equipment between speakers...


I've heard this over and over again, but wonder what the details are. I've just removed my cabinet and the equipment is on 3" platforms on the floor and on the fireplace hearth (at least I think it's a hearth). It does indeed seem much more interesting from a sound-stage perspective, with added resolution. This may be spurious, as there are other changes happening at the same time.

Nevertheless, my question for those in the know is... If I had a 13' wide, by 9' high front wall with my speakers 4' out from that wall, would a wall-to-wall book shelf with books, records, equipment (lets say 18" deep) be helpful or harmful? if helpful (difusing), then what of all this "don't put your equipment between your speakers" stuff? If harmful, is it the fact that the equipment is between the speakers or that there is anything between the speakers (other than wall)?

Given the choice, would you have the book shelf with equipment strategically (and artfully) placed, or would you have a dedicated audio stand (and not bookshelf) in between, or have nothing but wall in between (with equipment off to the side and long speaker cable runs).

Many thanks, as always.

Cheers
hatari

Showing 1 response by hatari

Thanks for the input. More facts may help you visualize, sorry it's a new house so no pics to help. My new room is about 13' around in a "U" shape with the front wall being the middle of the "U" (ie 13' sides to left and right). This room opens into a 21'x17' area, with the listening position just outside the U. My equipment rack is a 250lb wood behemoth custom made and I'll use SRA or similar under the equipment in time. Speakers are Verity Sarastros and they will be 4' from front wall (measured from back of speaker, these are rear-firing woofers).

So, I can:
A) have speakers on front wall and nothing else on that wall (seems to be the consensus thus far).

B) have bookshelves built across all of the front wall (18" deep, so about 3.5' behind the back of the speakers). Shelves will be full of books, LPs etc, and potentially some of my equipment if I ditch the dedicated stand.

C) Variations...have a single book shelf take up the middle-third of the front wall, with nothing behind the speakers OR have book shelves behind the speakers with nothing in the middle.

From a room aesthetic/usage, it would be easiest to have the equipment in the middle either on the dedicated rack (2' deep, so still 2' behind the back of the speakers) or on a book shelf. In my current room my rack sits between, but is roughly in line with the back of the speakers.

If the bookshelves work, I can have them designed to take the weight of my equipment and use SRA (or similar) stands to augment. I can have them designed of 2" veneered ply for rigidity and a cooler look. The turntable, however, would need to be on a shelf (3" high or so) within the book-shelf that is bigger and rigidly reinforced (it will sit on an SRA or similar stand as well). Again, the bookshelves can be completely excluded, or be only in the middle, or be only on the sides (of the front wall)

I can't do an adjacent room unfortunately.

Side placement of the rack can be OK, as I can build some sort of base-board runner to hide cables (great point). In a narrow room, however, having a chunky 250lb 2' deep rack taking up valuable side real-estate. The cost of cables to run bi-wire 13' or so is going to be horrific!

Not sure if the extra color helps or changes anything. Again, thanks for all the detailed and helpful comments.