Al, it may have more to do with your preamp and driving sources. Is the preamp a true fully balanced design, or does it just convert a single ended signal to support a balanced connector? In that case you'd be going through extra circuitry using the XLR for (maybe) no real benefit. Are you using long ICs? That may indicate an advantage for XLR, but unless the input impedance of the preamp is very high it may not really matter.
If, OTOH, you have both a source and a preamp that operates in a true fully balanced configuration then I think using XLR could very well be the better choice.
If, OTOH, you have both a source and a preamp that operates in a true fully balanced configuration then I think using XLR could very well be the better choice.