I'm waiting for mapman's response!
Does Mid-Woofer Size Relate to a Speaker's Realism
It could be argued that a small mid-woofer is 'quicker' in its response to signal-input and, therefore, more realistic in transient response. Is this true?
It could also be argued that a large mid-woofer is better able to reproduce the lower tones of the midrange in a more realistic manner. Is this true?
Is either choice better at realistic reproduction, overall?
[Since I do have strong views on the subject, as the O.P., I'd prefer to remain outside any ensuing discussion, as much as possible, on this one, if that's O.K.]
It could also be argued that a large mid-woofer is better able to reproduce the lower tones of the midrange in a more realistic manner. Is this true?
Is either choice better at realistic reproduction, overall?
[Since I do have strong views on the subject, as the O.P., I'd prefer to remain outside any ensuing discussion, as much as possible, on this one, if that's O.K.]