difference between CD recorder and PC burner

Has anybody had the chance to compare CDs created with a decent CD recorder and those created with a CD-R with a good sound card on a PC. At some point I will be replacing my Nak cassette deck with either a CD recorder or a CD-R on my computer. If I get a CD recorder, it will have to be a dual well recorder since I don't want to have a CD player and a CD recorder - I like things simple. The other alternative is just buying a better CD player and then buying a CD-R and a good sound card. Whenever I want to record I could just run a cable from the tape out of my receiver over to the sound card of the computer. I will most likely be recording more LPs than CDs, so whichever method I choose should have a good ADC on board. I don't need absolute high end sound (that's why I have scaled down to my Fisher 400 tubed receiver) but I don't want crap either. The CDs would be played only in the car which has a pretty decent sound system (although cassette based at the moment). I would appreciate hearing comments from anybody that has experience with both choices.

Cost is less on a pc per disc and gives better quality control over recording. You can get software for pc that will let you have input as to the final quality and there is plenty of free info on the web.
You can make bit-perfect copies on your PC without the sound card being a factor at all if you config your copier correctly. Some will tell you that the quality of the CDR and/or the duping speed will affect sound quality.
i found that if you like to make compilation disc's(single tracks from numerous albums) as i, a cd recorder will do a better job, i directly hook my cdp,tape,or tt(pre amp) to the recorder and burn at a 1:1 ratio, it far exceeds my dell pc for burning discs, most single well cdr's have the same recording features as a cassette recorder.
like you, i didn't want another cdp in the rig, but, i found a single well is much better for my purpose, i just slip it in on burning day................
Sogood51: If I buy one of the pro decks, I should be able to use the same CD-ROM disks that PCs use. I am just not sure if all CD players can play them back. But it sounds like using the HDD to store all the songs I want to record and then using SW to arrange them and burn them sounds like a good way to do this.

Kthomas: How can you config the CD burner without using the sound card. I need the ADC in the sound card to convert the analog LP into digital for the CD burner.

Dogeatpuppy: Probably a third of the tapes I make are compilation tapes. Can you just stop and start the recorder like a cassette deck? Is there a way to tell the recorder where each new track starts so that it makes a TOC?

Thanks for the responses guys. It will probably be a while before I make a decision. I am pretty sure that I cannot sell my Nak cassette deck for anything near what it is worth, so I may hang on to it for a while longer (at least until it needs to be repaired again). Besides that, I will have to buy a CD player for my car and my wife's car if I get rid of the cassette deck. I guess another alternative would be to find a CD changer that can be controlled by a separate remote. Then I could use the extra inputs on my casstte player to provide the sound.

I useed to burn my cdr's on my Macintosh G4 using Toast. I always thought they sounded pretty good. Not as good as the originals, but close enough. Especially, since I only use the cdr's for my car stereo. I learned to extract the music on to my hard drive, then burn the cd from the hard drive. This process produced superior cdr's than simply alowing the cd burner to read/write in segments. Additionally, the quality of the cdr's differ. The best I've used are Sony, Maxell and Fuji. The worst was Memorex.

However, this year I purchased an Alesis Masterlink 9600 High-Resolution Master Disk Recorder. This hard disk/cdr burner produces Red Book cd's and up to 24-bit/96kHz cd's.

All I can say is that all my favorite cdr's in my car are being replaced using the Alesis ML9600. The sound quality was far superior to the quality of cdr's from my Macintosh G4 computer. Hands down, no comparison and worth every penny. The Alesis Masterlink 9600 can be found new for under $1000.
Rosstaman,I just went to the alesis masterlink web site and that is a very nice recorder.
The Alesis Masterlink 9600 also does an excellent job recording vinyl onto cdr's.
There is also a difference between the type of blanks an audio recorderwill take and a PC burner will take. The stand alone CDRs use Audio CD blanks which cost more but have a "royalty" built in to the cost. There is also an issue with ability of some units to play burned/recorded CDs. check with the manufacturer.
Just curious... has any new product come out since this thread that the masterlink owners prefer?