Comparson Of 24/92 vs Non Upsampling DAC's


I have Revel F 50 speakers, BAT VK 500 BAt VK 5i and Audiomecca Mephisto 11x transport and Musical Fidelity DAC. Looking to upgrade DAC and am confused about upsampling vs. not. Have been looking at Audiomecca Ekianthus and Audionote 3.1 balanced. Would like to hear opinions of the sound of these two DAC's as well as discussion as to the differences in sound quality of upsampling vs. nonupsampling DAC's.

Also would like to know if there are any potential problems going with a non Audiomecca DAC with my exisiting transport.

Thank you

Rick
128x128rickrose

Showing 1 response by audioengr

They can both sound good, but when direct comparisons are done, the inner detail and vocal smoothness are usually superior on the upsampler due to the very high frequency filtering and the interpolation (if the implementation is done right). The Audionotes use the natural roll-off of the transformers (low-order) to achieve a more natural sound, which works well, but this also limits their high-frequency extension. Harpsichord, for instance, sounds very natural on an upsampler, but not as natural on the Audionote.

Its a matter of taste. The upsamplers can cause a bit of unnaturaleness (maybe not as smooth), but the non-upsamplers have other shortcomings.